Gemini 4 Carbon vs GPT-6 Astra: Complete Comparison and Report on Token Prices, Cost per Task, Agentic Benchmarks, and Speed

Gemini 4 Carbon is Google's frontier model, introduced on October 28, 2026 for a restricted group of cyber defenders and opened on November 10 to every paying Gemini API developer, to Gemini Enterprise and to Google AI Ultra subscribers. GPT-6 Astra is the OpenAI model that the company's system card, published on September 3, 2026, calls the most capable model it has ever broadly deployed; it is sold through the OpenAI API at $10 per million input tokens and $50 per million output tokens and is included in ChatGPT Plus, Pro and Business for Work and Codex. Both have context windows of roughly one million tokens, both reason before answering, and both are now generally available, which makes them the two flagship models a buyer is most likely to weigh against each other this month.
On list prices the gap is wide. Carbon costs $2 input and $10 output per million tokens until November 30, 2026, then $4 and $20 from December 1, so Astra's token rates are five times higher today and 2.5 times higher after the introductory period ends. Measured per completed task, the picture changes: Artificial Analysis records $5.48 per task for Carbon at high thinking against $3.24 for Astra at high effort, because Carbon spends far more tokens on the same work, and its runs take 33.8 minutes per task against 9.2 minutes for Astra. On directly comparable scores Carbon leads the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index (60 at high against 57 for Astra at max), Terminal-Bench 4.0 (65.2% against 59.1%) and AutomationBench-AA (77.8% against 68.5%), while Astra leads on FrontierCode-AA 2.0, GDP.pdf and CritPt v2.
The choice therefore follows the workload. Carbon is the better buy for long, input-heavy jobs such as reading large codebases or document sets, where its flat price across the whole window and its 96.2% GraphWalks long-context score count most. Astra is the better buy for interactive agent work where elapsed time and a predictable bill per task matter, and for teams already paying for ChatGPT Plus, Pro or Business, where Astra is part of the subscription. All prices in this report were checked on the official OpenAI and Google pages on November 15, 2026.
··········
GEMINI 4 CARBON AND GPT-6 ASTRA: RELEASE TIMELINE AND MODEL IDENTITY.
The two models reached general availability about ten weeks apart. OpenAI published Astra's system card on September 3, 2026, GitHub made the model generally available in Copilot the following day, and OpenAI's model catalog lists a single snapshot, gpt-6-astra. Carbon followed a two-step path. Google first offered it on October 28 to verified defenders through its Fairwind Program, then on November 10 opened the public model gemini-4-carbon on the paid tier of the Gemini API and in Google AI Studio, Android Studio, Gemini Enterprise, Google Antigravity, the Gemini app and AI Mode for Ultra subscribers. A separate gemini-4-carbon-cyber-permissive variant remains reserved for Fairwind participants.
Google's model card says Carbon is built on Gemini 4 Argon and uses more thinking tokens than Argon, with a knowledge cutoff of March 2026. OpenAI lists an April 30, 2026 cutoff for Astra and describes it as a reasoning model trained with reinforcement learning to think before it answers.
........
Item | Gemini 4 Carbon | GPT-6 Astra |
Developer | Google DeepMind | OpenAI |
API model ID | gemini-4-carbon | gpt-6-astra |
First availability | Oct 28, 2026 (Fairwind only) | Sep 3, 2026 |
General availability | Nov 10, 2026 | Sep 3, 2026 |
Knowledge cutoff | March 2026 | Apr 30, 2026 |
Input modalities | Text, image, audio, video | Text, image |
Output | Text | Text |
Specialized variant | gemini-4-carbon-cyber-permissive (Fairwind) | None listed on the model page |
........
··········
GEMINI 4 CARBON VS GPT-6 ASTRA API PRICING PER MILLION TOKENS.
Google publishes the Carbon rates on its Agent Platform pricing page and in the November 10 announcement. Until November 30 Carbon costs the same as Gemini 4 Argon, $2 input and $10 output per million tokens on the global endpoint, with implicit cache hits at $0.10. From December 1 every rate doubles. Regional (non-global) endpoints cost 10% more, the batch tier is half the standard rate, and the Priority tier costs 1.8 times standard. Google lists no cache-write charge and no long-context tier for Carbon, so a 900,000-token prompt is billed at the same per-token rate as a 9,000-token prompt.
OpenAI's Astra rates are $10 input, $1 cached input and $50 output, with cache writes at $12.50 for the 30-minute cache. Prompts above 272,000 input tokens are billed at twice the input and cache rates and 1.5 times the output rate for the whole request. Batch and Flex cost half of standard, and Fast mode, the former Priority tier, doubles the bill.
........
Price per 1M tokens | Carbon to Nov 30 | Carbon from Dec 1 | GPT-6 Astra |
Input (standard) | $2.00 | $4.00 | $10.00 |
Cached input | $0.10 | $0.20 | $1.00 |
Cache write | None charged | None charged | $12.50 (30 min) |
Output, thinking included | $10.00 | $20.00 | $50.00 |
Batch input / output | $1.00 / $5.00 | $2.00 / $10.00 | $5.00 / $25.00 |
Priority or Fast input / output | $3.60 / $18.00 | $7.20 / $36.00 | $20.00 / $100.00 |
Long-context rule | None listed | None listed | Over 272K input: 2x input, 1.5x output |
Regional endpoint uplift | +10% (non-global) | +10% (non-global) | +10% (regional processing) |
........
Two billing details change real costs. Google states that every processed token is billed, thinking tokens included, and that completed long-decode segments over 32,000 tokens are charged even if a later segment fails or times out. OpenAI applies the 272,000-token surcharge to the full request once the threshold is crossed, which makes a single very long prompt on Astra roughly ten times more expensive than the same prompt on Carbon at introductory prices.
··········
CONTEXT WINDOW, OUTPUT LIMITS AND REASONING CONTROLS FOR CARBON AND ASTRA.
The windows are almost identical in size and different in how they are shared. Carbon has a unified limit of 1,048,576 tokens that covers input and output together, thinking and function calls included. Its output has no separate cap beyond that window when long decodes are used, but a request without max_output_tokens gets a default budget of 65,536 tokens, and each foreground segment is limited to 65,536 tokens when streaming and 32,768 when not. Astra has a 1,050,000-token window with a fixed ceiling of 128,000 output tokens.
The reasoning controls differ more. Carbon exposes three thinking levels, low, medium and high, with medium as the default on the public model and high on the cyber-permissive variant; Google's guide says temperature, top_k and top_p are ignored and that the older thinking budget and minimal level return an error. Astra offers five effort levels, from low to max.
........
Specification | Gemini 4 Carbon | GPT-6 Astra |
Context window | 1,048,576 tokens, input and output shared | 1,050,000 tokens |
Maximum output | Window minus input (long decodes); default budget 65,536 | 128,000 tokens |
Reasoning settings | Low, medium (default), high | Low, medium, high, xhigh, max |
Sampling parameters | Temperature, top_k, top_p ignored | Not stated on the model page |
Caching | Implicit only, prefixes of 4,096+ tokens | Automatic cache with paid writes |
Explicit cache | Not supported | Not applicable |
Fine-tuning | Not listed | Not supported |
........
For tools, Google's Agent Platform guide lists function calling, structured output, Google Search grounding, code execution and URL context, plus agentic video understanding that is off by default. OpenAI lists web search, file search, image generation, code interpreter, a hosted shell, apply patch, skills, computer use, MCP and tool search in the Responses API for Astra. Grounding with Google Search is billed per query on Carbon; Google's Gemini API pricing lists 5,000 free requests a month shared across Gemini 3 and later models, then $14 per 1,000 queries.
··········
WHERE GEMINI 4 CARBON AND GPT-6 ASTRA ARE AVAILABLE, BY PLAN AND PLATFORM.
Astra reaches more paying users today. OpenAI includes it in ChatGPT Plus ($20 a month), the three Pro tiers ($100, $200 and $500) and Business Standard and Premium seats ($25 per user billed monthly, $20 billed annually), inside ChatGPT Work and Codex. OpenAI's help center estimates 5 to 45 local messages per five-hour window with Astra on Plus and Standard Business seats, against 15 to 160 for GPT-6.1 Sol, and says that GPT-6 Pro in chat, which is powered by Astra, is limited to the Pro plan. Free and Go accounts do not get Astra.
Carbon is limited to Google's top consumer tier. Google AI Ultra, at $99.99 a month for 5x Pro limits or $199.99 for 20x, includes Carbon in the Gemini app and in AI Mode in select countries, and Ultra subscribers can use it in Antigravity. Google AI Pro ($19.99) and Plus ($4.99) do not list it. Our guide to Gemini plans, pricing and features covers those tiers in detail.
........
Channel | Gemini 4 Carbon | GPT-6 Astra |
Direct API | Gemini API paid tier, AI Studio, Android Studio | OpenAI API (Build, Launch, Grow tiers; no free tier) |
Cloud platforms | Google Cloud Agent Platform: verified enterprise customers, global, us, eu | Amazon Bedrock (openai.gpt-6-astra); Google Cloud private preview |
Consumer subscription | Google AI Ultra, $99.99 or $199.99 a month | ChatGPT Plus $20, Pro from $100 |
Business subscription | Gemini Enterprise | ChatGPT Business $25 per user monthly, $20 annual |
Coding tools | Antigravity (Ultra); GitHub Copilot Pro+, Max, Business, Enterprise | Codex; GitHub Copilot Pro+, Max, Business, Enterprise |
Search product | AI Mode for Ultra, select countries | Not applicable |
Cyber variant | Fairwind Program only | Not listed |
........
Rate limits are published only by OpenAI: 5,000 requests and 1 million tokens per minute on the Build tier, 10,000 requests and 4 million tokens on Launch, and 15,000 requests and 40 million tokens on Grow. Google's Agent Platform guide says Carbon is offered to verified enterprise customers in select regions to protect capacity and security, without publishing per-minute figures in its documentation. In GitHub Copilot both models are generally available on the same four plans and are billed at provider list pricing under usage-based billing; GitHub's pricing table already lists Astra at $10/$50 with a long-context row, while Carbon's row had not yet appeared on November 15.
··········
HOW THE CARBON AND ASTRA BENCHMARKS WERE PRODUCED AND HOW FAR TO TRUST THEM.
Three kinds of figures exist for this pair, and they carry different weight. The strongest are the independent results from Artificial Analysis, which runs both models on the same tasks at several reasoning settings and publishes cost and time per task alongside the scores; its comparison page, read on November 15, uses Intelligence Index v5.0.1 and averages speed over the previous five days. The second kind is Google's Carbon model card, dated November 2026 with results "as of October 2026", which includes an Astra column; those Astra numbers were published by Google, and the card does not state Astra's effort setting for each row. The third is OpenAI's system card for Astra, which reports safety and alignment evaluations against GPT-5.6 Sol and contains no Carbon results, since Carbon did not exist when it was published.
Settings matter more than usual here. Carbon's highest setting is "high" and Astra's is "max", and the Artificial Analysis page shows Astra's score rising from 43 at low to 57 at max, so any comparison that does not name the setting can move by more than ten points. Google also notes that its cybersecurity figures reflect access through the Fairwind Program, which means the public gemini-4-carbon model runs with classifiers and refusal behavior that those test runs may not have faced.
··········
DIRECTLY COMPARABLE SCORES: ARTIFICIAL ANALYSIS RESULTS FOR CARBON AND ASTRA.
The table below sets each model's top setting against the other's, plus the middle settings that most API users run by default. Carbon at high leads six of the nine component evaluations against Astra at max; Astra leads FrontierCode-AA 2.0, GDP.pdf and CritPt v2 (Hard), and Astra's xhigh setting edges its own max result on GDP.pdf and CritPt.
........
Artificial Analysis evaluation | Carbon high | Carbon medium | Astra max | Astra high |
Intelligence Index v5.0.1 | 60 | 58 | 57 | 55 |
AA-Briefcase v1.1 (Elo) | 1,611 | 1,602 | 1,569 | 1,503 |
AutomationBench-AA | 77.8% | 77.6% | 68.5% | 66.6% |
Terminal-Bench 4.0 | 65.2% | 60.6% | 59.1% | 54.0% |
FrontierCode-AA 2.0 | 40.6% | 39.5% | 42.4% | 40.1% |
AA-Omniscience v1.1 | 54 | 47 | 42 | 45 |
GDP.pdf | 28.4% | 29.6% | 31.0% | 31.0% |
HLE-Diamond | 69.1% | 67.4% | 63.8% | 59.3% |
CritPt v2 (Hard) | 69.0% | 69.0% | 70.5% | 71.5% |
Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 | 64.8% | 62.4% | 63.3% | 59.5% |
........
The domain indexes on the same page follow the headline. Carbon at high scores 63 in finance and accounting, 62 in legal, 65 in engineering and 57 in healthcare; Astra at max scores 57, 56, 62 and 54 in the same areas. The gaps are three to six points, large enough to show a consistent lead and small enough that a buyer's own evaluation set could reverse a single category.
··········
[[ADPLUS_300x250_1]]
BENCHMARKS PUBLISHED BY ONLY ONE VENDOR FOR CARBON OR ASTRA.
Google's model card adds a second set of head-to-head figures that no independent group has reproduced for both models. On these, Carbon leads on most rows, and Astra leads on FrontierSWE 2, the software-engineering test in the card where Carbon is furthest behind. The card shows Claude Opus 5.5 ahead of both on OSWorld-2.1, which is outside this pair but useful context for computer-use buyers.
........
Benchmark (Google model card, Oct 2026) | Gemini 4 Carbon | GPT-6 Astra |
Vals Index v2.2 | 70.4% | 65.0% |
FrontierSWE 2 | 61.2% | 65.5% |
SWE-sweep | 9.6% | 9.5% |
Agents' Last Exam v1.1 | 77.4% | 73.1% |
OSWorld-2.1 (offline subset) | 81.5% | 80.9% |
AutomationBench (Zapier) | 53.9% | 41.4% |
Vending-Bench 2 (bank balance) | $16,484 | $15,515 |
GraphWalks BFS, 256K to 1M (F1) | 96.2% | 71.8% |
RiemannBench | 80.0% | 72.0% |
Chartography | 72.5% | 71.0% |
CWE-bench | 71.0% | 68.0% |
ExploitGym | 54.8% | 42.4% |
SEC-bench Pro | 88.2% | 85.4% |
........
The GraphWalks row is the widest gap anywhere in the published data: 24.4 points on a test of reasoning across inputs between 256,000 and one million tokens. It supports the long-context advantage that Carbon's flat pricing already suggests. On OpenAI's side, the Astra system card reports HealthBench Professional at 64.7 and HealthBench Hard at 36.6 (length-adjusted, revised on September 22), and a corrected SecureBio World Class Bio score of 59.2% without web search; Google publishes no Carbon result on those tests.
··········
GEMINI 4 CARBON VS GPT-6 ASTRA: COST PER TASK AND TOKEN CONSUMPTION.
Artificial Analysis converts each run into dollars per task at list prices, and on that measure the pair ranks in the opposite order from its per-token rates. Carbon costs between $4.68 and $5.48 per task depending on the thinking level, at the introductory $2/$10 rates shown on the page. Astra costs $1.42 at low, $3.24 at high and $6.24 at max. Carbon's low setting costs more per task than its medium setting, which indicates longer runs at low thinking rather than cheaper ones.
Because every Carbon rate doubles on December 1, the same runs would cost about $9.36 to $10.96 per task at the new prices if token use stays the same. That projection is a calculation from the published rates; Artificial Analysis has not published December figures.
........
Setting | Index score | Cost per task (AA) | Projected from Dec 1 | Time per task |
Carbon high | 60 | $5.48 | $10.96 | 33.8 min |
Carbon medium | 58 | $4.68 | $9.36 | 28.8 min |
Carbon low | 54 | $5.22 | $10.44 | 28.1 min |
Astra max | 57 | $6.24 | $6.24 | 21.8 min |
Astra xhigh | 55 | $3.66 | $3.66 | 11.7 min |
Astra high | 55 | $3.24 | $3.24 | 9.2 min |
Astra medium | 52 | $2.73 | $2.73 | 7.3 min |
........
The arithmetic implies that Carbon uses several times more tokens per task than Astra. With Astra's output priced five times higher today, Carbon at high still costs 1.7 times as much per task as Astra at high; Google's model card confirms that Carbon "may use more tokens to maximize performance, especially at higher thinking levels". Astra's own token efficiency was measured by Artificial Analysis at launch in September at about 27,000 output tokens per task at max effort, on the earlier version of the index.
··········
CARBON AND ASTRA COSTS FOR THREE TYPICAL WORKLOADS.
Per-task averages hide how the two price structures treat different inputs, so the following examples apply each model's list rates to the same token counts, computed in Python. The assumptions are stated for each case. The token counts are held equal for both models to isolate price; in practice Carbon would generate more thinking tokens on reasoning-heavy work, as the per-task data above shows, which narrows its advantage on the output side.
The coding agent session assumes 40 requests totaling 2 million input tokens, of which 1.6 million are cache reads and 400,000 are new tokens, plus 150,000 output tokens; on Astra the new tokens are billed at the $12.50 cache-write rate because the loop caches them for the next turn. The long-document job is a single request with a 500,000-token prompt and a 10,000-token answer, which triggers Astra's long-context surcharge. The support assistant handles 10,000 requests a day for 30 days, each with 6,000 input tokens (70% cached) and 800 output tokens.
........
Workload | Carbon to Nov 30 | Carbon from Dec 1 | GPT-6 Astra | Astra vs Carbon (Dec 1) |
Coding agent session | $2.46 | $4.92 | $14.10 | 2.9x |
500K-token document, one request | $1.10 | $2.20 | $10.75 | 4.9x |
Support assistant, one month | $3,606 | $7,212 | $18,660 | 2.6x |
Same support month on Batch | $1,803 | $3,606 | $9,330 | 2.6x |
........
The long-document case shows the structural difference. Astra's 272,000-token threshold raises its input rate to $20 and output to $75 for the whole request, while Carbon keeps a single rate across its window, so the gap grows from 2.5 times on list output prices to nearly five times on this job. The support case is the closest to a pure per-token comparison, because short prompts and short answers leave little room for Carbon's longer reasoning to add cost.
··········
SPEED AND LATENCY OF GEMINI 4 CARBON AND GPT-6 ASTRA.
Carbon generates tokens faster, and Astra finishes tasks sooner. Artificial Analysis measures Carbon at 60 to 61 output tokens per second at medium and high thinking, against 38 to 43 for Astra across its settings. Time to first token tells the other half: Carbon at medium returns its first token in 22.2 seconds and at high in 72.1 seconds, while Astra at medium starts in 7.5 seconds and at high in 61.5 seconds.
........
Speed measure (AA, 5-day average) | Carbon medium | Carbon high | Astra medium | Astra high |
Output speed (tokens/s) | 60 | 61 | 41 | 42 |
Time to first token | 22.24 s | 72.06 s | 7.46 s | 61.49 s |
End-to-end, single request | 75.48 s | 179.95 s | 128.24 s | 226.65 s |
Time per agentic task | 28.8 min | 33.8 min | 7.3 min | 9.2 min |
........
On a single request Carbon wins end to end, because its higher throughput outweighs its slower start. On multi-step tasks the result flips by a factor of three to four, which matches the token data: Carbon produces more tokens per step and takes more steps. Google's model card lists "occasional slowness or timeouts" among Carbon's known limitations, and OpenAI sells Fast and Ultrafast modes for Astra at two and six times standard prices for users who need lower latency.
··········
SAFETY RATINGS, CYBER ACCESS RULES AND DATA HANDLING FOR CARBON AND ASTRA.
OpenAI rates Astra as Critical in cybersecurity under its Preparedness Framework, the first OpenAI model to reach that level, and deploys it with misalignment monitoring on all tool-using inference and a more conservative refusal boundary for users flagged as high risk. Google's Safety and Security Report says it cannot rule out that Carbon reaches the cyber and biological uplift critical capability levels, a finding carried forward from Argon, and judges residual risk below those levels with classifiers, activation probes, agent monitoring and account enforcement in place. Google reports no material capability change from Argon, so Carbon did not receive a full new assessment.
The prompt-injection figures cannot be compared directly. Google reports a 0% attack success rate for Carbon on Gray Swan's indirect prompt injection benchmark; OpenAI reports an estimated 8.5% for Astra on Gray Swan's IPI Arena, using 1,810 curated attacks and 15 attempts per scenario on a safeguards-enabled checkpoint. The vendors used different attack sets and settings, and Google's own announcement says resistance to prompt injection remains an area for continued improvement.
For enterprise buyers, both providers charge a 10% uplift for regional processing, and Google classifies Carbon as a Google Frontier Model under Section 34 of its Cloud service terms, available to verified enterprise customers in select regions. Carbon's cyber-permissive variant is priced at the December rates from the start and excluded from promotions.
··········
WHAT GOOGLE AND OPENAI HAVE NOT PUBLISHED ABOUT CARBON AND ASTRA.
Several gaps limit the comparison. Google has not published per-minute rate limits for Carbon on the Gemini API, and Carbon's rates did not appear on the Gemini API pricing pages or in GitHub's Copilot pricing table on November 15, so its API rates in this report come from Google's Agent Platform pricing page and the November 10 announcement. Google gives no effort setting for the Astra figures in its model card. OpenAI's Astra launch post and its ChatGPT models help article were unavailable when this comparison was prepared, so plan details rely on OpenAI's pricing page and its usage help article, which describes message counts as estimates rather than guarantees.
No independent organization has yet published Carbon prices after December 1, so the December cost figures above are projections from list rates. Artificial Analysis has not published a Carbon result on GDPval-AA, and neither vendor has published a like-for-like test of prompt-injection resistance for both models.
··········
WHICH TO CHOOSE: GEMINI 4 CARBON OR GPT-6 ASTRA BY WORKLOAD.
The published data points to a split by workload. The table summarizes where each model has the stronger measured case.
........
Workload or buyer | Better choice | Deciding facts |
Long-context analysis (300K+ tokens) | Gemini 4 Carbon | Flat rate across the window; GraphWalks 96.2% vs 71.8%; Astra surcharge above 272K |
High-volume chat or support | Gemini 4 Carbon | 2.6x cheaper per month in the example even after Dec 1 |
Interactive coding agents | GPT-6 Astra | 9.2 min vs 33.8 min per task; $3.24 vs $5.48 per AA task |
Terminal and automation agents | Gemini 4 Carbon | Terminal-Bench 4.0 65.2% vs 59.1%; AutomationBench-AA 77.8% vs 68.5% |
Repository-level software engineering | GPT-6 Astra | FrontierSWE 2 65.5% vs 61.2%; FrontierCode-AA 42.4% vs 40.6% |
ChatGPT Plus, Pro or Business users | GPT-6 Astra | Included in Work and Codex at no extra API cost |
Video and audio inputs | Gemini 4 Carbon | Accepts audio and video; Astra accepts text and images only |
Batch processing before Nov 30 | Gemini 4 Carbon | $1 / $5 batch rates, one fifth of Astra's |
........
For a team deciding today, the strongest case for Carbon is a long-input or high-volume API workload, which stays cheaper on Carbon even after the December 1 price change doubles its rates. The strongest case for Astra is agent work measured in finished tasks per hour, where its shorter runs and lower cost per task offset token rates five times higher. Readers comparing Carbon with OpenAI's mid-priced model can see our Gemini 4 Carbon vs GPT-6.1 Sol comparison, and Astra's position against Anthropic's latest model is covered in Claude Fable 5.2 vs GPT-6 Astra. The details of Carbon's public rollout are in our report on Google opening Gemini 4 Carbon to API developers and AI Ultra.
··········
FOLLOW US FOR MORE.
·····
DATA STUDIOS
·····
datastudios.org




