How Asset Retirement Obligations and Decommissioning Liabilities Are Measured under IAS 37, IAS 16, and ASC 410

Asset retirement obligations (AROs) and decommissioning liabilities represent the future costs an entity must incur to dismantle, remove, or restore a site at the end of an asset’s useful life. These obligations arise from legal or constructive duties linked to the operation of long-lived assets, such as oil wells, nuclear facilities, mines, refineries, and wind farms. Under IFRS (IAS 37 – Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets; IAS 16 – Property, Plant and Equipment) and US GAAP (ASC 410 – Asset Retirement and Environmental Obligations), entities must record both a liability for the present value of expected outflows and a corresponding asset capitalized as part of the related asset’s cost.

·····

.....

How asset retirement obligations arise.

AROs are triggered by legislation, regulation, or contractual requirements obliging an entity to restore an environment or dismantle an asset.Examples include:

• Dismantling offshore platforms or oil rigs.

• Restoring land disturbed by mining operations.

• Decommissioning power plants or nuclear facilities.

• Removing leasehold improvements at lease termination.

The obligation arises when the asset is installed or the condition that creates the obligation exists, not when the settlement occurs decades later.

The liability represents the present value of the future restoration costs, discounted to the reporting date using a pre-tax rate reflecting the time value of money and risk characteristics of the obligation.

·····

.....

Recognition and measurement under IFRS (IAS 37 and IAS 16).

1) Initial recognition.At the time the obligation is incurred, recognize a decommissioning liability and a corresponding asset as part of the related PPE’s cost.

Journal entry (IFRS – initial recognition):

• Debit: Property, Plant and Equipment – Decommissioning Asset 1,200,000

• Credit: Decommissioning Liability (Provision) 1,200,000

2) Subsequent measurement.

• The liability is increased over time for the unwinding of discount (accretion of interest).

• The asset is depreciated over its useful life.

• Any change in estimate of the timing, amount, or discount rate adjusts both the liability and the asset (unless the asset is fully depreciated, in which case the change goes directly to P&L).

Journal entries (IFRS – subsequent periods):Accretion of interest on liability

• Debit: Finance Cost – Unwinding of Discount 60,000

• Credit: Decommissioning Liability 60,000

Depreciation of the capitalized asset (10-year life)

• Debit: Depreciation Expense 120,000

• Credit: Accumulated Depreciation 120,000

3) Change in estimates (IFRS 16/IAS 37 interaction).Reassess when new information emerges (e.g., inflation revisions, technology advances, regulatory changes).

• Increase in liability: adjust asset’s carrying amount.

• Decrease in liability: reduce asset to zero first, then recognize remaining reduction as gain.

Example (IFRS – liability increased by 200,000):

• Debit: Property, Plant and Equipment 200,000

• Credit: Decommissioning Liability 200,000

4) Measurement inputs.Discount rate reflects risk-free rate adjusted for liability-specific risk factors. Inflation may be incorporated in cash flows or discount rate (but not both).

·····

.....

Recognition and measurement under US GAAP (ASC 410).

1) Scope and initial measurement.ASC 410 requires recognition of an ARO when a legal obligation exists and a reasonable estimate of fair value can be made.Fair value = present value of expected future cash flows to settle the obligation, discounted using a credit-adjusted risk-free rate.

Journal entry (US GAAP – initial recognition):

• Debit: Asset Retirement Cost (ARC) 1,200,000

• Credit: Asset Retirement Obligation (ARO) 1,200,000

2) Subsequent measurement.

• The ARO liability increases over time by accretion expense (similar to interest).

• The ARC asset is depreciated over its useful life using an appropriate method (usually straight-line).

• If estimates change, adjust both liability and asset prospectively using the current discount rate for upward revisions and original discount rate for downward revisions.

Journal entries (GAAP – subsequent periods):Accretion of liability

• Debit: Accretion Expense 55,000

• Credit: Asset Retirement Obligation 55,000

Depreciation of asset

• Debit: Depreciation Expense 100,000

• Credit: Accumulated Depreciation 100,000

3) Changes in estimates (ASC 410-20).Revisions of expected cash flows require remeasurement of the ARO at the current credit-adjusted risk-free rate.

• Increase: adjust both liability and asset upward.

• Decrease: adjust both downward; if asset is fully depreciated, recognize gain.

4) Settlement.When the obligation is settled (e.g., decommissioning completed):

• Debit: Asset Retirement Obligation (full amount)

• Credit: Cash (actual cost)

• Recognize any difference as gain or loss on settlement.

·····

.....

Comparative table: IFRS vs US GAAP.

Aspect	IFRS (IAS 37 / IAS 16)	US GAAP (ASC 410)
When recognized	When a legal or constructive obligation arises	When a legal obligation exists and fair value can be reasonably estimated
Measurement basis	Present value of expected future outflows	Fair value using expected cash flows and credit-adjusted risk-free rate
Discount rate	Pre-tax rate reflecting risk characteristics	Credit-adjusted risk-free rate
Subsequent measurement	Unwind discount (finance cost) and adjust for estimate changes	Accrete liability and revise for changes in estimates
Change in estimate	Adjust asset and liability; if asset fully depreciated, through P&L	Adjust asset and liability using current or original rate
Revaluation of asset	If PPE under revaluation model, adjust asset through OCI	Not applicable
Disclosure emphasis	Nature, timing, uncertainties, discount rates	Reconciliation of ARO liability and description of changes
IFRS vs GAAP terminology	“Decommissioning liability” and “provision”	“Asset retirement obligation” (ARO)

Both frameworks produce similar P&L effects: depreciation of the capitalized asset and accretion expense on the liability.

·····

.....

Presentation and disclosures.

Balance sheet presentation (IFRS/GAAP):

Liabilities	Amount (USD)
Non-Current Liabilities:
Asset Retirement Obligation	1,380,000
Other Long-Term Liabilities	240,000

Assets	Amount (USD)
Property, Plant and Equipment	9,500,000
Less: Accumulated Depreciation (ARO Component)	(340,000)
Carrying Value of ARO Asset Component	860,000

Disclosure requirements:

• Description of the nature of obligations and expected settlement timing.

• Key assumptions (discount rate, inflation, expected life).

• Reconciliation of beginning and ending liability balances.

• For IFRS: significant uncertainties in timing or amount.

• For GAAP: roll-forward of ARO liability, showing accretion, settlements, and revisions.

Example (GAAP disclosure table):

Reconciliation of ARO (USD)	Amount
Beginning balance	1,200,000
Accretion expense	55,000
Revision in estimate	120,000
Settlements	(75,000)
Ending balance	1,300,000

·····

.....

Journal entries for common scenarios.

1) Initial recognition (both frameworks):

• Debit: Asset Retirement Cost / PPE 1,200,000

• Credit: Asset Retirement Obligation / Provision 1,200,000

2) Accretion of discount:

• Debit: Accretion Expense 60,000

• Credit: Liability 60,000

3) Depreciation of capitalized asset:

• Debit: Depreciation Expense 120,000

• Credit: Accumulated Depreciation 120,000

4) Increase in estimate (IFRS/GAAP):

• Debit: PPE / ARC 200,000

• Credit: ARO Liability 200,000

5) Settlement of obligation (actual cost < liability):

• Debit: ARO Liability 1,300,000

• Credit: Cash 1,250,000

• Credit: Gain on Settlement 50,000

·····

.....

Impact on financial performance and ratios.

AROs affect both balance sheet leverage and EBITDA patterns:

• Initial recognition increases assets and liabilities equally, with no immediate P&L effect.

• Over time, depreciation and accretion increase expenses, reducing operating profit.

• Changes in estimates create volatility in asset values and finance costs.

• Analysts monitor the ratio of ARO liability to total assets and its growth trend as a proxy for long-term environmental and compliance exposure.

Failure to recognize or remeasure AROs can understate liabilities and distort ROA and debt metrics.

·····

.....

Operational considerations.

Accounting for decommissioning obligations requires coordination between engineering, environmental, and finance teams. Key steps include:

• Estimating cash flow timing and cost escalation.

• Updating discount rates periodically.

• Maintaining audit evidence for models and assumptions.

• Tracking each obligation’s vintage year to unwind discount correctly.

• Integrating ARO data with fixed-asset subledgers for depreciation synchronization.

Under both IFRS and US GAAP, consistent and transparent recognition of AROs provides users with a clearer view of the true life-cycle cost of long-lived assets and the entity’s environmental stewardship obligations.

·····

.....

FOLLOW US FOR MORE.

DATA STUDIOS

.....[datastudios.org]