How joint arrangements are classified and reported under IFRS 11 and ASC 323

Joint arrangements are partnerships or ventures where two or more parties share control, typically through contractual agreement. They are vital in sectors like energy, construction, and technology, where entities pool resources and expertise. IFRS 11 (Joint Arrangements) and US GAAP (ASC 323 – Investments—Equity Method and Joint Ventures) both determine how such arrangements are classified and measured, but they differ in how joint operations and joint ventures are defined and consolidated.

Both standards aim to ensure that reporting reflects the rights and obligations of each investor rather than merely the legal form of the arrangement.

·····

.....

How joint control is defined.

Joint control exists when decisions about relevant activities require the unanimous consent of all parties sharing control. Neither venturer can unilaterally direct activities without the other’s agreement.

Indicators of joint control:

• Contractual sharing of strategic decisions.

• Equal voting rights or veto power.

• Protective rights that prevent unilateral control.

Under IFRS 11, if one party can control without the consent of the others, the arrangement is not jointly controlled.Under US GAAP, joint control exists when no single party can control but each can block actions of the other participants.

·····

.....

Classification under IFRS 11.

IFRS 11 identifies two distinct types of joint arrangements based on rights and obligations:

1) Joint operations.

• Each party has rights to assets and obligations for liabilities.

• Accounting: recognize share of assets, liabilities, revenues, and expenses directly in the investor’s own financial statements (similar to proportionate consolidation).

Example:Company A and B jointly own an oil field, each responsible for 50% of costs and entitled to 50% of production.

Entries for Company A:

• Debit: Inventory (oil) 500,000

• Debit: Joint Operation Expense 250,000

• Credit: Cash/Payables 750,000

2) Joint ventures.

• Each party has rights to the net assets of the arrangement.

• Accounting: recognize investment using the equity method (IAS 28).

• Share of profit/loss recorded as one-line item in income statement.

Example:Investment cost 1,000,000; 40% ownership; JV reports profit 400,000.

• Debit: Investment in JV 160,000

• Credit: Share of Profit from JV 160,000

Carrying amount increases to 1,160,000.

·····

.....

Classification under US GAAP (ASC 323).

US GAAP does not distinguish between “joint operations” and “joint ventures” as separate accounting models.Instead, it applies the equity method to all corporate or LLC-type joint ventures when the investor has joint control and significant influence, typically 20–50% ownership.

Key points under ASC 323:

• Use equity method unless joint venture qualifies as a VIE requiring consolidation (ASC 810).

• Recognize investment initially at cost.

• Adjust carrying amount for share of profit or loss and dividends.

Example (GAAP):Initial investment 1,500,000; JV net income 300,000; dividends 100,000.

• Debit: Investment in JV 150,000

• Credit: Income from JV 150,000

• Debit: Cash 50,000

• Credit: Investment in JV 50,000

Ending carrying amount = 1,600,000.

·····

.....

Comparative table: IFRS 11 vs ASC 323.

Aspect	IFRS (IFRS 11 + IAS 28)	US GAAP (ASC 323)
Control definition	Joint control = unanimous consent required	Joint control = no single party can control unilaterally
Types of arrangements	Joint operations, joint ventures	Joint ventures only
Accounting for joint operations	Recognize direct share of assets/liabilities	No equivalent (use legal form)
Accounting for joint ventures	Equity method under IAS 28	Equity method under ASC 323
Measurement of investment	Cost plus share of post-acquisition profits	Same
Loss recognition	Up to investment carrying amount	Up to investment carrying amount unless guaranteed
Reassessment of joint control	Required if agreement changes	Required for reconsideration events
Disclosures	Nature, financial effects, commitments, restrictions	Nature, summarized financial info, risks and obligations

·····

.....

Example – joint operation vs joint venture.

Scenario	Form	Rights/Obligations	Accounting Treatment (IFRS)
Two oil companies jointly operate a refinery sharing output 60/40	Joint operation	Direct rights to assets, obligations for costs	Recognize 60% share of assets/liabilities
Two companies form a separate entity to market products	Joint venture	Rights to net assets	Apply equity method

Illustration (joint venture): Investment in JV: 2,000,000Share of profit: 300,000Dividends received: 120,000

Journal entries:

• Debit: Investment in JV 300,000

• Credit: Share of Profit 300,000

• Debit: Cash 120,000

• Credit: Investment in JV 120,000

Carrying amount: 2,180,000.

·····

.....

Disclosures required.

IFRS 12 disclosure requirements:Entities must disclose:

• Nature, purpose, and activities of joint arrangements.

• Extent of ownership and voting rights.

• Summarized financial data of material joint ventures.

• Commitments and contingent liabilities related to joint operations.

ASC 323 disclosures:

• Name and description of joint venture.

• Investor’s ownership interest and accounting method.

• Summarized assets, liabilities, revenues, and profit.

• Undistributed earnings of equity investees.

Example summary disclosure:

Joint Arrangement	Type	Ownership	Carrying Amount (USD)	Share of Profit (USD)
EnergyCo Refinery	Joint Operation	50%	2,400,000	300,000
Horizon JV	Joint Venture	40%	1,600,000	160,000

·····

.....

Journal entries summary.

1) Joint operation (IFRS):

• Debit: PPE / Inventory / Expense xx

• Credit: Cash / Payables xx

2) Joint venture (IFRS/GAAP):

• Debit: Investment in JV xx

• Credit: Cash xx

3) Share of profits (IFRS/GAAP):

• Debit: Investment in JV xx

• Credit: Income from JV xx

4) Dividends received:

• Debit: Cash xx

• Credit: Investment in JV xx

5) Impairment of investment:

• Debit: Impairment Loss xx

• Credit: Investment in JV xx

·····

.....

Impact on financial performance and ratios.

Under IFRS, joint operations increase assets, liabilities, and revenue line-by-line, influencing leverage and turnover ratios.Under US GAAP, equity method presentation keeps such investments off-balance-sheet, leading to lower reported assets and liabilities but potentially higher margins.Analysts often adjust for proportional consolidation when comparing IFRS and GAAP companies in capital-intensive industries.

Example: IFRS joint operation 50% of project adds 5,000,000 in assets and 2,000,000 in liabilities; GAAP equity method shows only investment of 3,000,000.

·····

.....

Operational considerations.

For accurate reporting of joint arrangements:

• Review contractual terms to determine rights and obligations.

• Align accounting policies among joint operators.

• Monitor related-party transactions and performance guarantees.

• Test investments for impairment under IAS 36 or ASC 323 annually.

• Reassess joint control when ownership or voting rights change.

Proper classification and consistent application ensure transparency in reporting shared economic interests under both IFRS 11 and ASC 323.

·····

.....

FOLLOW US FOR MORE.

DATA STUDIOS

.....[datastudios.org]