top of page

Pulley shuts down December 8, 2026: moving your cap table, 409A and ASC 718 to Carta

39 minutes ago
9 min read
Cover with the title Pulley shuts down December 8, 2026: moving your cap table, 409A and ASC 718 to Carta over a night city skyline, Data Studios original cover

Pulley, the equity management and cap table platform for startups, has announced that it will stop all operations on December 8, 2026. Its official shutdown FAQ, published on September 15, 2026, names Carta as the exclusive migration partner, states that Carta can accept an existing Pulley 409A valuation and fair market value as they are, and warns that a company without a new agreement in place by the shutdown date loses access to its cap table. Pulley data stays available in a limited format through the Pulley app until January 31, 2027.


For a controller, CFO or fractional finance lead at a venture-backed company, the shutdown is a deadline with three finance consequences. The ownership record that supports every option grant, SAFE conversion and fundraising model has to move to another system without losing a share. The 409A valuation that supports option strike prices has to stay valid through the transition. The ASC 718 stock-based compensation expense booked in the general ledger has to continue on the same basis, so that the next audit sees one consistent expense history built on one set of assumptions.


The comparison that a finance team now faces is narrower than the old Carta vs Pulley choice. Pulley's own path leads to a 12-month Carta agreement, while the FAQ also allows a company to sign with another provider before December 8. Plan features, prices and dates quoted below were verified on Pulley's and Carta's official pages on November 17, 2026, three weeks before the shutdown date.


··········


PULLEY SHUTDOWN DATES AND WHAT STOPS ON DECEMBER 8, 2026.


Pulley's FAQ sets out a short sequence. A customer first opts in by logging in to Pulley and consenting to share its contact and contract details with Carta. Opting in does not commit the company to migrating. Carta then sends a 12-month agreement, and the customer has two weeks from the day the agreement arrives to sign it. After signature, Carta contacts the company with timing and practical steps, such as confirming shareholder contact information, and runs the migration.


Pulley states that it will not help migrate customers to any provider other than Carta. A company that prefers a different equity management platform can still move, but it carries out the export and the rebuild without Pulley's assistance. Pulley's team remains available for questions until December 8, 2026.


........


Date

What happens according to Pulley

September 15, 2026

Shutdown FAQ published

Opt-in (no fixed date)

Customer consents to share details with Carta

Agreement arrival + 2 weeks

Deadline to sign the 12-month Carta agreement

December 8, 2026

Pulley stops operations; no new agreement means no cap table access

January 31, 2027

End of limited read access to Pulley data


........


With three weeks left before December 8, a company that has not opted in yet should treat the two-week signing window as the binding constraint. The FAQ also states that a customer signing with Carta receives a credit for any unused, prepaid balance on its Pulley subscription. The FAQ does not mention cash refunds, so a company that chooses another provider should ask Pulley support directly about prepaid fees.


··········


THE CARTA MIGRATION PATH FOR PULLEY CUSTOMERS.


Carta's support guide for Pulley customers describes four steps on its side. The customer opts in through Pulley, signs the Carta agreement when it arrives, and Carta schedules and runs the migration. During the data transfer, the Pulley account briefly goes read-only. Once the cap table is live on Carta, the company reviews the migrated data, sets up integrations and invites its team.


Carta's guidance on switching cap table providers adds three preparation points. The company should coordinate with its law firm before migration so that counsel can spot-check the data after import. The Carta implementation manager provides a checklist of the exports and legal documents required. The company should gather current email addresses for every active stakeholder so that invitations can go out as soon as the cap table is live. Carta describes a typical migration as covering the current cap table and the core equity and financing documents that support it, and asks companies to flag unusual instruments in advance.


The read-only window has a practical effect on the finance calendar. Option grants approved by the board, exercises in progress and SAFE closings should be entered and settled in Pulley before the migration slot, or held until the Carta cap table is confirmed. A grant recorded in neither system during the transfer is the most likely source of a reconciliation break.


··········


CARTA PLANS AFTER PULLEY: 409A AND ASC 718 COVERAGE BY TIER.


Pulley sold annual plans with published prices. Carta names its plans for private corporations on its comparison page but did not show dollar prices on the pages verified on November 17, 2026, so the cost of the 12-month agreement depends on the terms each company receives. The table maps the finance features that matter most during the move.


........


Plan

Published price

409A valuations

ASC 718 reporting

Pulley Startup

$1,200 per year, 25 stakeholders

Not listed

Not listed

Pulley Growth

$3,500 per year, 40 stakeholders

Included

Not listed

Pulley Enterprise

Contact sales

Included

Included

Carta Launch

Free, under 25 stakeholders and under $1M raised

Not included

Not listed

Carta Build

Not published

Not listed

Not listed

Carta Grow

Not published

Included at no additional cost

Not listed

Carta Scale

Not published

Included at no additional cost

GAAP (ASC 718) and IFRS reporting


........


The mapping has a direct consequence for budgeting. A company on Pulley Growth that relied on included 409A valuations needs at least Carta Grow to keep valuations inside the subscription. A company that used Pulley's Enterprise tier for ASC 718 reports sits at Carta Scale, the plan that Carta's comparison page associates with GAAP and IFRS financial reporting. A company that calculated stock compensation expense outside Pulley, in a spreadsheet or through its auditor, can choose a lower tier and keep its own calculation, provided the grant data it reads comes from the new cap table.


Carta Launch is free for companies with fewer than 25 stakeholders and less than $1 million raised, with no credit card required. Carta lists the need for a 409A valuation as one of the triggers for moving to a paid plan, so an early-stage company planning its first option grants should not assume that Launch covers the next twelve months.


··········


409A VALUATIONS DURING A CAP TABLE MIGRATION.


Pulley's FAQ states that Carta can accept Pulley's existing 409A and FMV as-is, with the customer providing a copy of the report. After that valuation expires, Carta's valuation team becomes the provider, and Carta will also support the defense of Pulley's prior 409A work.


Carta's own 409A guidance gives the limits that finance teams need for planning. A 409A valuation is valid for a maximum of 12 months from its effective date, and it expires earlier if a material event occurs, meaning any significant business change that could reasonably affect the stock price. A valuation by an independent appraiser provides a presumption of reasonableness, so the IRS has to prove that it is grossly unreasonable. Outside safe harbor, deferred compensation becomes taxable immediately, interest accrues, and an additional 20 percent tax applies, with the burden falling mainly on option holders.


For an illustrative valuation with an effective date of March 15, 2026, the latest refresh date is March 14, 2027, assuming no material event. A financing round or another significant change in the business before that date may bring the expiry forward, because it could reasonably affect the stock price. Option grants approved after such an event should wait for the new valuation, whichever platform hosts the cap table.


··········


RECONCILING THE PULLEY CAP TABLE BEFORE AND AFTER MIGRATION.


The safest control is to export the fully diluted cap table from Pulley before the read-only window, save it with the export date, and compare it line by line with the first Carta report after migration. The example below uses an illustrative company; the numbers are not from any real cap table.


........


Security class (illustrative)

Shares

Fully diluted %

Common, founders

7,500,000

65.22%

Common, exercised options

150,000

1.30%

Series Seed preferred

2,250,000

19.57%

Options outstanding

1,100,000

9.57%

Pool available for grant

500,000

4.35%

Fully diluted total

11,500,000

100.00%


........


Issued and outstanding shares in this example total 9,900,000, and the fully diluted count of 11,500,000 adds outstanding options and the unissued pool. Every class total on Carta should match these figures exactly, with no rounding differences, because share counts are whole numbers. Percentages may differ in the second decimal only if the two systems round differently.


Three items deserve a separate check. Unconverted SAFEs are not shares and appear in neither column, so the list of SAFE holders, purchase amounts, valuation caps and discounts should be compared as a separate schedule; the accounting for those instruments is covered in SAFE accounting under ASC 480 and IAS 32. Each option grant should carry the same grant date, strike price, vesting start date and schedule, because these fields drive both employee vesting and the expense calculation. Cancelled and expired grants should return to the pool in both systems on the same dates.


··········


ASC 718 EXPENSE CONTINUITY: A WORKED TIE-OUT.


Stock compensation expense depends on data that sits in the cap table: grant date, number of options, grant-date fair value and vesting schedule. A migration that changes any of these fields, or a new system configured with a different attribution method, changes the expense. Carta's ASC 718 guidance states that it allocates expense using the graded straight-line method as the default amortization method for profits interest units with time-based vesting, which concerns LLC structures. A corporation should confirm which attribution method its Carta reports use and make sure it matches the policy applied in prior periods.


Take an illustrative grant of 48,000 options with a grant-date fair value of $0.62 per option, granted on July 1, 2025, vesting over four years with a one-year cliff and monthly vesting afterwards. Total compensation cost is $29,760. At October 31, 2026, sixteen months of service have been rendered and 15,000 options have vested.


........


Measure at October 31, 2026

Amount

Total grant-date fair value

$29,760.00

Cumulative expense, straight-line

$9,920.00

Cumulative expense, graded (tranche by tranche)

$20,614.44

Grant-date value of vested options

$9,300.00

Unrecognized cost, straight-line

$19,840.00


........


Under US GAAP, an award with graded vesting and only a service condition may be expensed straight-line over the total service period or tranche by tranche, as a policy choice, and under the straight-line method the cumulative expense can never be lower than the grant-date value of the vested portion. Here the straight-line cumulative expense of $9,920 is above the $9,300 floor. The two methods are explained in graded vesting under ASC 718 vs IFRS 2. The difference of $10,694.44 between the two methods on a single grant shows why the attribution setting has to be checked before the first post-migration close.


Under the straight-line policy, the monthly expense for this grant is $620.00, and the October entry is the same before and after the migration if the data moved correctly.


........


Account

Debit

Credit

Stock-based compensation expense

$620.00


Additional paid-in capital


$620.00

Total

$620.00

$620.00


........


The tie-out test is simple. Run the expense report for the same period in both systems while Pulley is still readable, or compare Carta's report with the expense already booked in the ledger. Any difference points to a changed grant field, a different attribution method, a different forfeiture policy or a grant that was modified, the last of which is covered in ASC 718 vs IFRS 2 award modifications.


··········


PULLEY TO CARTA MIGRATION CHECKLIST FOR CONTROLLERS.


The checklist below collects the steps from the two vendors' guidance and the controls described above, in the order a finance team would run them.


........


Step

Owner

Timing

Opt in through the Pulley app

Admin

Now

Sign the 12-month Carta agreement

CFO or CEO

Within 2 weeks of arrival

Export fully diluted cap table, grant list, SAFE schedule

Controller

Before read-only window

Save current 409A report and FMV

Controller

Before read-only window

Export ASC 718 expense report to date

Controller

Before read-only window

Freeze grants, exercises and SAFE closings

Legal and finance

During transfer

Compare class totals and grant fields on Carta

Controller and counsel

First week on Carta

Confirm attribution method and forfeiture policy

Controller

Before next close

Download remaining Pulley records

Controller

Before January 31, 2027


........


Two exports carry most of the audit risk. The ASC 718 history supports every expense entry already in the ledger, and auditors may ask for it after Pulley's read access ends. The 409A reports support the strike prices of every outstanding option. Both should be stored in the company's own document system as well as in the new platform.


··········


PULLEY SHUTDOWN: DECISIONS LEFT TO EACH COMPANY.


The dates are fixed by Pulley: operations stop on December 8, 2026, the Carta agreement must be signed within two weeks of arrival, and read access ends on January 31, 2027. Pulley's FAQ states that Carta can accept existing Pulley 409A valuations, so a current valuation can carry over to Carta until it expires or a material event occurs.


The open points are commercial and accounting choices. Carta does not publish prices on the plan pages checked, so the cost of the 12-month agreement, and whether a Pulley Growth or Enterprise customer needs Carta Grow or Scale, depends on each quote. A company may still choose another provider, without Pulley's help. On the accounting side, continuity of ASC 718 expense depends on the grant data arriving intact and on the attribution and forfeiture settings matching prior policy, which only the company's own reconciliation can confirm.


··········


FOLLOW US FOR MORE.


·····


DATA STUDIOS


·····


datastudios.org


bottom of page