top of page

Standard cost variances under ASC 330 and IAS 2: inventory vs COGS

5 hours ago
10 min read
Cover reading Standard cost variances under ASC 330 and IAS 2: inventory vs COGS over a night city skyline. Data Studios original cover

Manufacturers that run a standard costing system carry inventory at predetermined unit costs during the year and collect the differences between standard and actual cost in variance accounts. At a reporting date those variances cannot simply stay where they are. Under both ASC 330 Inventory and IAS 2 Inventories, standard cost is an acceptable measurement technique only when the result approximates actual cost, so significant variances that relate to goods still on hand must be allocated between ending inventory and cost of goods sold, while abnormal costs and unabsorbed fixed overhead go straight to expense.


The two frameworks reach almost the same answer on the allocation itself. Both require fixed production overhead to be absorbed on the basis of normal capacity, both exclude abnormal waste and idle facility costs from inventory, and both treat standard costs as a convenience that must be reviewed and kept current. The differences sit around the allocation: US GAAP still allows LIFO and the retail method, it measures some inventories at the lower of cost or market, and it prohibits the reversal of write-downs that IFRS permits.


The practical stakes are larger than they look in a month-end close. A plant that books all variances to cost of goods sold every month understates ending inventory when variances are unfavorable and overstates it when they are favorable, and the error carries into gross margin, inventory covenants and the tax provision. In the worked example below, charging every variance to cost of sales would leave finished goods $13,300 below the cost that ASC 330 and IAS 2 require.


··········


WHEN STANDARD COSTS ARE ACCEPTABLE UNDER ASC 330 AND IAS 2.


Both standards start from the same principle: inventory is measured at cost, and cost includes all costs of purchase, costs of conversion and other costs incurred in bringing the goods to their present location and condition. The general rules on what enters cost are covered in our overview of how inventory is measured and reported under IAS 2 and ASC 330. A standard cost is a shortcut to that cost, and each framework accepts it on conditions.


IAS 2 permits techniques such as the standard cost method for convenience if the results approximate cost. The standards are expected to reflect normal levels of materials and supplies, labor, efficiency and capacity utilization, and they must be reviewed regularly and revised in the light of current conditions. A standard that is several years old, or one built on a capacity level the plant no longer reaches, fails that test.


ASC 330 follows the same logic. Standard costs are acceptable when they are adjusted at reasonable intervals to reflect current conditions, so that at the balance sheet date they reasonably approximate costs computed under one of the recognized cost flow bases, such as FIFO, average cost or LIFO. The standard cost itself is never the measurement basis. It is a bookkeeping device that has to land on an accepted basis by the reporting date.


Two consequences follow for the variance accounts. First, a variance that represents a real cost of producing the goods (higher material prices, normal inefficiencies, wage increases) belongs in the cost of whatever was produced, whether that output is still in inventory or has been sold. Second, a variance that represents a cost the standards exclude from inventory (abnormal waste, idle capacity) is an expense of the period regardless of where the units are.


··········


WHICH VARIANCES ARE CAPITALIZED AND WHICH ARE EXPENSED.


The classification of each variance drives the whole allocation. Price and rate variances usually reflect what the materials and labor cost, and they are allocated. Efficiency and usage variances are allocated to the extent they fall within normal operating conditions, and the abnormal part is expensed. Fixed overhead requires a separate calculation because the volume variance depends on the capacity level the company actually reached.


Under both frameworks the allocation of fixed production overhead to units is based on the normal capacity of the production facilities, meaning the production expected on average over a number of periods under normal circumstances, taking into account loss of capacity from planned maintenance. When actual production is lower than normal capacity, the fixed overhead per unit is not increased, and the unallocated overhead is recognized as an expense in the period. When production is abnormally high, the fixed overhead per unit is reduced so that inventory is not measured above cost. The cost behavior behind absorption costing is discussed in our article on absorption, variable and standard costing in practice.


Both standards also list costs that are excluded from inventory and expensed as incurred: abnormal amounts of wasted materials, labor or other production costs, storage costs unless necessary in the production process before a further stage, administrative overhead that does not contribute to bringing inventory to its present location and condition, and selling costs. ASC 330 gives examples of abnormal costs such as idle facility expense, excessive spoilage, double freight and rehandling costs.


........


Variance

Usual treatment

Allocated to

Material price variance

Allocate

RM, WIP, FG and COGS

Material usage, normal

Allocate

WIP, FG and COGS

Material usage, abnormal waste

Expense

Period cost

Labor rate variance

Allocate

WIP, FG and COGS

Labor efficiency, normal

Allocate

WIP, FG and COGS

Variable overhead variances

Allocate

WIP, FG and COGS

Fixed overhead below normal capacity

Expense

Period cost

Fixed overhead spending, absorbed share

Allocate

WIP, FG and COGS


........


The material price variance needs an extra step when it is recognized at the point of purchase, which is the common design in ERP systems. Part of that variance relates to kilograms still sitting in raw materials, so a share is allocated to raw materials inventory before the rest flows into production.


··········


STANDARD COST VARIANCES: IFRS VS US GAAP.


The allocation mechanics do not differ in substance between the frameworks. The differences come from the surrounding rules on cost formulas and measurement, and they affect how the allocated variances behave after the reporting date.


........


Topic

US GAAP (ASC 330)

IFRS (IAS 2)

Standard cost allowed

Yes, if adjusted to approximate cost

Yes, if results approximate cost

Fixed overhead basis

Normal capacity

Normal capacity

Abnormal costs

Expensed as incurred

Expensed as incurred

LIFO

Permitted

Prohibited

Retail method

Permitted

Permitted if it approximates cost

Write-down measure

LCNRV; LCM for LIFO and retail

Lower of cost and NRV

Reversal of write-downs

Prohibited

Required when NRV recovers


........


For a US company on LIFO, the allocated variances become part of the cost of the current year layer, so the allocation affects the LIFO reserve as well as ending inventory. For a company reporting under IFRS, the allocated variances become part of FIFO or weighted average cost, and any subsequent write-down to net realizable value is reversed, up to the amount originally written down, when net realizable value recovers. A group that reports under IFRS with US subsidiaries on LIFO needs a conversion adjustment for the variances capitalized in LIFO layers.


··········


WORKED EXAMPLE: ALLOCATING STANDARD COST VARIANCES AT YEAR END.


A single-product manufacturer uses a standard costing system. The illustrative figures below are computed for this example. Normal capacity is 40,000 units a year and budgeted fixed overhead is $240,000, giving a standard fixed overhead rate of $6.00 per unit.


........


Cost element

Standard

Cost per unit

Direct materials

2 kg at $5.00

$10.00

Direct labor

0.5 hours at $30.00

$15.00

Variable overhead

0.5 hours at $8.00

$4.00

Fixed overhead

$240,000 / 40,000 units

$6.00

Standard cost


$35.00


........


During the year a two-month shutdown for an equipment failure cut output to 30,000 units. The company sold 24,000 units and held 6,000 units in finished goods at year end, with no work in process and no opening inventory. It bought 70,000 kg of material at $5.20 and used 63,000 kg, of which 1,000 kg were lost in a contaminated batch that management classifies as abnormal waste. Labor worked 15,600 hours at $31.00. Actual variable overhead was $126,000 and actual fixed overhead was $246,000.


The ledger closes the year with these variances, all unfavorable: material price $14,000 (70,000 kg at $0.20), material usage $15,000 (3,000 kg at $5.00), labor rate $15,600, labor efficiency $18,000 (600 hours at $30.00), variable overhead $6,000 ($1,200 spending and $4,800 efficiency), fixed overhead spending $6,000 and fixed overhead volume $60,000. The total is $134,600.


The fixed overhead calculation shows why the volume variance cannot be capitalized. Actual fixed overhead divided by normal capacity is $6.15 per unit ($246,000 / 40,000). The 30,000 units produced can absorb $184,500, and the remaining $61,500 is unallocated overhead caused by the shutdown, which both frameworks require to be expensed. Since the standard cost system applied $180,000, only $4,500 of the fixed overhead variances is capitalizable.


........


Component

Amount

Treatment

Price variance on 7,000 kg in raw materials

$1,400

Raw materials inventory

Abnormal waste, 1,000 kg at $5.20

$5,200

Expense

Unallocated fixed overhead

$61,500

Expense

Allocable production variances

$66,500

FG 20%, COGS 80%

Total variances

$134,600



........


The allocable pool of $66,500 is made up of the price variance on material used in normal production ($12,400), the normal usage variance ($10,000), the labor rate and efficiency variances ($15,600 and $18,000), the variable overhead variance ($6,000) and the capitalizable fixed overhead ($4,500). Because all production finished during the year, the pool is prorated on units: 6,000 of 30,000 units (20%) are in finished goods and 24,000 (80%) were sold, so $13,300 goes to finished goods and $53,200 to cost of goods sold.


The year-end entry closes every variance account. Abnormal waste and unallocated overhead are shown on a separate line here so they can be disclosed or presented apart from ordinary cost of sales.


........


Account

Debit

Credit

Cost of goods sold, allocated variances

$53,200


Finished goods inventory

$13,300


Raw materials inventory

$1,400


Abnormal production costs, expense

$66,700


Material price variance


$14,000

Material usage variance


$15,000

Labor rate variance


$15,600

Labor efficiency variance


$18,000

Variable overhead variance


$6,000

Fixed overhead spending variance


$6,000

Fixed overhead volume variance


$60,000

Total

$134,600

$134,600


........


After the entry, finished goods are carried at $223,300, or $37.2167 per unit. That figure can be checked independently: allocable actual production cost is $1,116,500 (material of 62,000 kg at $5.20, labor of $483,600, variable overhead of $126,000 and fixed overhead of $184,500), and $1,116,500 divided by 30,000 units gives the same $37.2167. Raw materials end at $36,400, which is 7,000 kg at the actual price of $5.20. Cost of goods sold is $893,200 before the $66,700 of abnormal costs, for a total charge to the income statement of $959,900.


··········


PRESENTATION AND DISCLOSURE OF VARIANCES AND ABNORMAL COSTS.


IAS 2 requires disclosure of the accounting policies adopted in measuring inventories, including the cost formula, the carrying amount of inventories in classifications appropriate to the entity, the amount of inventories recognized as an expense during the period, and the amount of any write-down and of any reversal of a write-down. An entity that presents expenses by function usually includes abnormal production costs and unallocated overhead within cost of sales, and many add a separate disclosure when the amounts are significant. A company that adopts IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements will apply its rules on operating expenses classified by function and its specified disclosures by nature when it presents these costs.


Under US GAAP the basis of stating inventories must be disclosed, including the cost flow assumption, and a significant change in that basis must be disclosed with its effect. SEC registrants using LIFO also disclose the excess of replacement or current cost over the stated LIFO value. Large abnormal charges such as a shutdown are often described in management's discussion of gross margin, and the inventory measurement policy should state that standard costs are adjusted to approximate actual cost.


Year-end adjustments of this kind also matter for interim reporting and for the physical count. Count differences recorded at standard can themselves carry variances, which is why the variance allocation and the shrinkage entries described in our article on physical inventory count under ASC 330 should be prepared from the same quantities.


··········


COMMON ERRORS IN STANDARD COST VARIANCE ALLOCATION.


The most frequent error is closing all variances to cost of goods sold every month without testing whether the amount relating to ending inventory is material. When standards are current and variances are small, expensing them in full is a reasonable practical choice, provided the effect on inventory is immaterial. When standards are stale, the cumulative variance can be a significant percentage of inventory and the shortcut no longer approximates cost.


The second error is capitalizing an unfavorable volume variance. Spreading the full actual fixed overhead over a reduced output inflates the unit cost exactly in the periods when the plant performed worst, which both standards prohibit. The opposite case also needs care: in a period of abnormally high production, a favorable volume variance has to reduce inventory so that units are not carried above cost.


A third error is treating every usage or efficiency variance as normal. The split between normal inefficiency and abnormal waste is a judgement, and it should rest on documented criteria such as scrap rates outside a defined tolerance, identified incidents or production stoppages, applied consistently from period to period.


A fourth error is prorating on the wrong base. Units work for a single product with no work in process. A multi-product plant usually allocates on the standard cost of each inventory category, separately for material variances and conversion variances, because a material price variance should not be spread over goods that contain no material of that type. The lower of cost and net realizable value test is then applied after the variances have been allocated, as explained in our article on lower of cost or market and net realizable value.


··········


PRACTICAL CHECKLIST FOR YEAR-END VARIANCE ALLOCATION.


Confirm that standards were reviewed during the year and reflect current prices, rates and normal capacity. Extract every variance account balance and classify each one as allocable or as a period expense. Recompute fixed overhead absorption using actual fixed overhead divided by normal capacity, and expense the unabsorbed portion. Identify abnormal waste, spoilage and idle time from production records and value them at actual cost. Allocate the purchase price variance between raw materials and production, then prorate the allocable pool across work in process, finished goods and cost of goods sold on an appropriate base. Run the net realizable value test on the adjusted carrying amounts, and document the materiality assessment when variances are expensed in full.


··········


STANDARD COST VARIANCES UNDER ASC 330 AND IAS 2: KEY CONCLUSIONS.


Under both ASC 330 and IAS 2, a standard cost is a measurement convenience whose result must approximate actual cost at the reporting date, so allocable variances follow the units into raw materials, work in process, finished goods and cost of goods sold. Fixed overhead is absorbed at normal capacity in both frameworks, which forces unabsorbed overhead from low production into period expense, and abnormal waste is never capitalized.


The open judgement areas are the definition of normal capacity, the boundary between normal inefficiency and abnormal waste, the allocation base in a multi-product plant and the materiality threshold that allows variances to be expensed in full. The framework differences lie outside the allocation: LIFO layers and the lower of cost or market test under US GAAP, and the reversal of write-downs under IFRS.


··········


FOLLOW US FOR MORE.


·····


DATA STUDIOS


·····


datastudios.org


bottom of page