ASC 360 vs IAS 36: how corporate assets are allocated in impairment tests

A headquarters building, a shared data center or a group-wide ERP platform supports every business line of a company, yet none of these assets earns cash on its own. Under IAS 36 Impairment of Assets, the carrying amount of such a corporate asset is pushed down into the impairment test of the cash-generating units it serves, either unit by unit on a reasonable and consistent basis or, when no such basis exists, at the level of the smallest group of units to which part of it can be allocated. Under US GAAP, ASC 360-10 has no comparable allocation step: a corporate asset is tested with the asset group at the lowest level of largely independent cash flows, which for a headquarters facility is often the entity as a whole.
The two models can produce very different numbers from the same facts. In the illustrative example below, a company with three operating units and a USD 300 thousand headquarters records an impairment loss of USD 210 thousand under IFRS when the headquarters is allocated to the units, USD 36 thousand under IFRS when it can only be tested with the whole group, and USD 30 thousand under US GAAP, where the recoverability screen uses undiscounted cash flows and the headquarters is never spread across the operating asset groups.
The question arises every time an impairment indicator hits one part of a business that shares central assets with other parts: a downturn in one region, the loss of a major customer in one product line, a restructuring that closes a site. It also arises when the corporate asset itself shows signs of impairment, for example when a company moves to hybrid work and leaves floors of its headquarters empty.
··········
WHAT IAS 36 MEANS BY A CORPORATE ASSET.
IAS 36 defines corporate assets as assets other than goodwill that contribute to the future cash flows of both the cash-generating unit under review and other cash-generating units. Paragraph 100 of the standard describes their two distinctive characteristics: they do not generate cash inflows independently of other assets or groups of assets, and their carrying amount cannot be fully attributed to the unit under review.
Typical examples are a head office building, research facilities serving several divisions, central IT infrastructure, a shared distribution center and a group treasury or shared-service platform. The label depends on facts. A warehouse that serves only one division belongs to that division's cash-generating unit and is tested inside it like any other operating asset; the same warehouse serving three divisions is a corporate asset.
Because a corporate asset has no separate cash inflows, paragraph 101 explains that its recoverable amount usually cannot be determined on its own unless management has decided to dispose of it. If there is an indication that a corporate asset may be impaired, the recoverable amount is determined for the cash-generating unit or group of units to which the asset belongs, and that unit or group is compared with its carrying amount including the corporate asset.
··········
HOW IAS 36 ALLOCATES CORPORATE ASSETS TO CASH-GENERATING UNITS.
Paragraph 102 requires an entity testing a cash-generating unit for impairment to identify all the corporate assets that relate to that unit, and then sets out two routes.
If a portion of the carrying amount of a corporate asset can be allocated on a reasonable and consistent basis to the unit, the entity compares the carrying amount of the unit, including that allocated portion, with the unit's recoverable amount. Any impairment loss is recognized under paragraph 104.
If a portion cannot be allocated on a reasonable and consistent basis, the entity follows three steps. It first compares the carrying amount of the unit, excluding the corporate asset, with its recoverable amount and recognizes any loss. It then identifies the smallest group of cash-generating units that includes the unit under review and to which a portion of the corporate asset can be allocated on a reasonable and consistent basis. Finally, it compares the carrying amount of that group, including the allocated portion of the corporate asset, with the recoverable amount of the group. Paragraph 103 points to Illustrative Example 8 accompanying IAS 36, which applies these requirements to corporate assets.
IAS 36 does not prescribe an allocation key. Common bases are relative carrying amounts of the units, carrying amounts weighted by the remaining useful lives of the units' assets, revenue, headcount or floor space used. The test the standard sets is that the basis is reasonable and applied consistently from period to period, so a change of key in the year an indicator appears needs a defensible reason documented at the time.
Once a loss is identified, paragraph 104 allocates it first to any goodwill allocated to the unit or group and then to the other assets, including the allocated portion of the corporate asset, pro rata on the basis of their carrying amounts. Paragraph 105 sets a floor: no asset may be reduced below the highest of its fair value less costs of disposal, if measurable, its value in use, if determinable, and zero. Any amount that cannot be absorbed because of the floor is spread pro rata across the remaining assets of the unit or group.
··········
CORPORATE ASSETS UNDER ASC 360-10: ASSET GROUPS AND THE ENTITY-LEVEL TEST.
ASC 360-10, which codified FASB Statement No. 144, takes a different starting point. Long-lived assets held and used are grouped with other assets and liabilities at the lowest level for which identifiable cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of other assets and liabilities. That asset group is the unit of account for the impairment test.
The guidance recognizes that in limited circumstances a long-lived asset, with a corporate headquarters facility as the standard example, does not have identifiable cash flows that are largely independent of other assets and liabilities and of other asset groups. In that case the asset group for that long-lived asset includes all assets and liabilities of the entity. A headquarters that serves the whole company is therefore normally tested at the entity level, and only when there is an indicator that the carrying amount of that entity-wide group may not be recoverable.
There is no US GAAP requirement to spread the headquarters across the operating asset groups. Each operating asset group is tested on its own assets and liabilities, and the corporate asset enters a test only at the level at which it has identifiable cash flows. Where a corporate asset is partly sublet or vacated and generates its own lease income, practice often treats the affected portion as a separate asset group, which is a facts-and-circumstances judgment.
The measurement mechanics also differ from IAS 36. ASC 360-10 applies a two-step approach. The carrying amount of the asset group is first compared with the sum of the undiscounted cash flows expected from its use and eventual disposition. Only if the carrying amount exceeds that sum is an impairment loss measured, as the excess of carrying amount over fair value. The loss is allocated to the long-lived assets of the group pro rata on the basis of their carrying amounts, without reducing any individual long-lived asset below its fair value when that fair value is determinable without undue cost and effort. Restoration of a previously recognized impairment loss is prohibited, and the reduced carrying amount becomes the new cost basis.
When goodwill is also involved, US GAAP tests the long-lived asset groups under ASC 360 before goodwill is tested at the reporting unit level under ASC 350, so the order of the tests affects the carrying amounts used in the goodwill test. The site's article on how goodwill impairment is tested under IAS 36 and ASC 350 covers that second step.
··········
CORPORATE ASSET ALLOCATION: IAS 36 VS ASC 360 COMPARISON.
........
Issue | IAS 36 | ASC 360-10 |
Unit of account | Cash-generating unit | Asset group |
Corporate asset | Allocated to CGUs if a reasonable, consistent basis exists | Not allocated to operating asset groups |
No allocation basis | Smallest group of CGUs that can absorb it | Entity-level asset group |
First screen | None; direct comparison with recoverable amount | Undiscounted cash flows |
Loss measured against | Higher of value in use and FVLCD | Fair value |
Loss allocation | Goodwill first, then pro rata | Pro rata to long-lived assets |
Floor per asset | Highest of FVLCD, value in use, zero | Fair value, if determinable |
Reversal | Allowed except goodwill | Prohibited |
........
The comparison explains why IFRS reporters tend to recognize corporate asset impairments earlier and more often. Allocation puts part of the headquarters into the test of a struggling unit, and the comparison is made with a discounted recoverable amount without an undiscounted screen in front of it.
··········
[[ADPLUS_300x250_1]]
WORKED EXAMPLE: A HEADQUARTERS ALLOCATED UNDER IAS 36 AND TESTED UNDER ASC 360.
The figures are illustrative and in USD thousands. A company has three operating units, A, B and C, and a headquarters building with a carrying amount of 300 that serves all three. Units A and C face impairment indicators at year end. Management allocates the headquarters on the basis of the units' relative carrying amounts, which it has applied consistently in prior years. There is no goodwill, and the fair values less costs of disposal of individual assets do not bind the paragraph 105 floor.
........
Unit | Carrying amount | HQ allocated | Total tested | Recoverable amount | Impairment loss |
A | 500 | 100 | 600 | 510 | 90 |
B | 400 | 80 | 480 | 654 | 0 |
C | 600 | 120 | 720 | 600 | 120 |
Total | 1,500 | 300 | 1,800 | 1,764 | 210 |
........
Under paragraph 104 the loss of each unit is shared between the unit's own assets and its slice of the headquarters in proportion to their carrying amounts. For unit A, 90 is split 75 to the unit's assets (500 of 600) and 15 to the headquarters (100 of 600). For unit C, 120 is split 100 to the unit's assets (600 of 720) and 20 to the headquarters (120 of 720). The headquarters carrying amount falls from 300 to 265, unit A's assets from 500 to 425 and unit C's assets from 600 to 500.
If management could not find a reasonable and consistent basis to allocate the headquarters, paragraph 102(b) would apply. Each unit is first tested without the headquarters: A at 500 against 510, B at 400 against 654 and C at 600 against 600, so no loss arises at unit level. The smallest group to which the headquarters can be allocated is the whole company, with a carrying amount of 1,800 against a recoverable amount of 1,764, giving a loss of 36. Allocated pro rata to the carrying amounts of 500, 400, 600 and 300, that loss reduces unit A by 10, unit B by 8, unit C by 12 and the headquarters by 6.
Under ASC 360-10 the same company tests asset groups A, B and C without the headquarters. The illustrative undiscounted cash flows are 540 for A, 700 for B and 580 for C. Groups A and B pass the recoverability test. Group C fails, because its carrying amount of 600 exceeds undiscounted cash flows of 580, and its fair value of 570 gives a loss of 30. The headquarters is tested with the entity-level group only because an indicator exists for the company as a whole; with an illustrative entity-level carrying amount of 2,050 against undiscounted cash flows of 2,900, no loss is recognized on it.
........
Account | Debit | Credit |
IFRS: Impairment loss (profit or loss) | 210 | |
IFRS: Accumulated impairment, unit A assets | 75 | |
IFRS: Accumulated impairment, unit C assets | 100 | |
IFRS: Accumulated impairment, headquarters | 35 | |
US GAAP: Impairment loss (operating expenses) | 30 | |
US GAAP: Long-lived assets, asset group C | 30 |
........
Debits equal credits in both entries: 210 against 75, 100 and 35 under IFRS, and 30 against 30 under US GAAP. Under US GAAP the 30 is allocated across the long-lived assets of group C pro rata to their carrying amounts and becomes part of their new cost basis. Under IFRS the 210 can be reversed in later periods, within the paragraph 117 limit of the carrying amount that would have existed without the impairment, if the estimates used to determine recoverable amount change. Under IFRS, depreciation of the headquarters is recalculated on its reduced carrying amount of 265 from the next period, while under US GAAP only the long-lived assets of group C are depreciated on a new, lower basis.
The analysis of how impairment of non-financial assets is tested and recognized under IAS 36 and ASC 360 sets out the general recoverability mechanics behind these numbers, and the piece on how impairment of cash-generating units is modeled under IAS 36 using multi-scenario discounted cash flows covers how the recoverable amounts of 510, 654 and 600 would be built.
··········
PRESENTING AND DISCLOSING CORPORATE ASSET IMPAIRMENTS.
Under IAS 36 an impairment loss on an asset carried at cost is recognized immediately in profit or loss. The disclosures cover the amount of impairment losses by class of assets, the line items in which they are included, and, for material losses, the events and circumstances that led to the loss, a description of the cash-generating unit, the amount of the loss allocated to it, whether recoverable amount is value in use or fair value less costs of disposal, and the key assumptions used. When a corporate asset has been allocated, the allocation basis is part of the judgment that preparers typically explain alongside the unit disclosures.
Under US GAAP the impairment loss on assets held and used is reported within income from continuing operations before income taxes and, where an operating income subtotal is presented, within it. The notes describe the impaired assets, the facts and circumstances leading to the impairment, the amount of the loss, the method used to determine fair value and, for public entities, the segment in which the impaired asset group is reported. Fair value measurement disclosures under ASC 820 apply to the nonrecurring measurement of the impaired group.
··········
COMMON ERRORS IN ALLOCATING CORPORATE ASSETS.
The first frequent error under IFRS is leaving corporate assets out of the cash-generating unit test altogether, which overstates headroom in every unit and pushes any problem to a group-level test that is rarely performed. A second is choosing an allocation key in the year of the impairment that minimizes the loss, such as switching from carrying amounts to revenue when the troubled unit has low revenue, without a documented business reason.
A third error is inconsistency between carrying amount and recoverable amount. If the headquarters is allocated to a unit, the cash flows used for value in use must include the cash outflows for running and maintaining the headquarters attributable to that unit; including the asset while excluding its costs inflates the recoverable amount. Paragraph 105 floors are also often ignored, which can drive a corporate asset below its own fair value less costs of disposal.
Under US GAAP the typical mistakes are allocating the headquarters into operating asset groups by analogy to IFRS, which can create losses ASC 360 would not recognize, and skipping the entity-level evaluation when the company as a whole shows indicators such as a sustained market capitalization below book value. Dual reporters also mix the frameworks by using discounted cash flows for the US recoverability screen. The process for component depreciation under IAS 16 and ASC 360 interacts with these tests too, because the components of a headquarters building carry different remaining lives that influence weighted allocation keys.
··········
CORPORATE ASSET IMPAIRMENT UNDER ASC 360 AND IAS 36: JUDGMENT AREAS AND CHECKLIST.
The standards settle the structure. IAS 36 requires corporate assets to be included in the test of every cash-generating unit they serve, either through an allocated portion or through the smallest group of units that can absorb them, and it measures losses against a discounted recoverable amount that can later be reversed. ASC 360-10 tests a headquarters at the level at which it has identifiable cash flows, usually the entity, applies an undiscounted screen before measuring any loss at fair value, and never restores a loss once recognized.
The judgment sits in the facts: whether an asset is corporate or belongs to one unit, which allocation key is reasonable, whether a vacated or sublet part of a building has become its own asset group, and how central running costs are reflected in each unit's cash flows. A practical sequence for a year-end file is to list every shared asset with its carrying amount and the units it serves; document the allocation key and confirm it matches prior years; under IFRS, run the paragraph 102 test for each unit and, where no basis exists, the group-level test; under US GAAP, test each operating asset group and decide whether an entity-level indicator requires testing the headquarters with all assets and liabilities of the entity; check the floors on individual assets; and record the journal entries and disclosures separately for each framework when the company reports under both.
··········
FOLLOW US FOR MORE.
·····
DATA STUDIOS
·····
datastudios.org




