ChatGPT vs Claude for Excel Analysis: Calculations, Text Extraction, and Multi-Sheet Workflows

ChatGPT is best for working with Excel when you need accurate calculations, formula checks, data cleaning, and automated summaries, using Python behind the scenes.

Claude is more suited for text extraction, comment synthesis, and navigating very large or multi-file spreadsheets, though it does not calculate formulas.

For simple math across many sheets, Claude can handle totals quickly in memory, but ChatGPT offers more reliable and flexible aggregation when precision is critical.

ChatGPT for reading and analyzing Excel files

ChatGPT, in the Plus, Team, or Enterprise plans, allows you to upload .xlsx files up to around 50 MB directly into the chat. The Advanced Data Analysis module interprets each sheet, detects tables, data types, and relationships, and performs complex calculations, formula auditing, data cleaning, chart generation, and summaries. You can request automated formula checks, outlier detection, creation of calculated columns, and even export a modified Excel file or a cleaned CSV. You don’t need to write code: ChatGPT generates and runs the necessary Python scripts in the background.

Persistent Python state across prompts

Once a workbook is loaded, ChatGPT’s sandbox keeps every variable alive between messages, so you can iteratively tweak code, reuse cleaned DataFrames, and build multi-step pipelines (e.g., filter → forecast → visualize) without re-reading the file each time.

Named-range and table object awareness

When an .xlsx contains structured tables or named ranges, ChatGPT can reference them directly—“Plot ‘Sales_Q1’ versus ‘Marketing_Spend’”—instead of relying on A1-style coordinates, reducing off-by-one errors and making follow-up prompts more natural.

PivotTable and dynamic-array synthesis

Beyond raw formulas, the model can generate Python that recreates Excel PivotTables (using pandas.pivot_table) and even writes the resulting dynamic-array formulas (=LET() / =MAP()) back into the sheet, yielding live, refreshable summaries once you reopen the file.

Natural-language formula explainers

A new helper pattern—explain_formula("=XLOOKUP(A2,IDs,Emails,,0)")—returns a conversational breakdown of each argument, alternative functions, and common pitfalls, acting as an instant documentation layer for legacy workbooks.

Locale and formatting conversions

ChatGPT now detects region-specific conventions (decimal comma vs point, dd/mm/yyyy vs mm/dd/yyyy) and can output a parallel workbook with all numbers, dates, and list separators converted for a different locale—crucial when sharing dashboards across subsidiaries.

Synergy with Excel’s native Python

If your organization has Excel’s built-in =PY() enabled, ChatGPT can embed compatible Python snippets directly into cells, letting the workbook itself run forecasts or regressions locally—no further cloud calls required—while the chat remains your conversational IDE.

•••

Claude for reading and analyzing Excel files

Claude, in the Pro, Max, or Team plans with the Analysis Tool enabled, accepts Excel files up to 30 MB. It fully imports values, text, and notes, retaining them in its contextual memory, which can exceed 200k tokens. This allows Claude to search, summarize, and extract text even from dozens of sheets or multiple files uploaded in a single session. Claude excels when you need to quickly extract textual content, compile “quotes,” or create discursive summaries from scattered notes and clauses. However, it does not perform native calculations: it ignores formulas, returns only the final displayed values, and cannot reconstruct cell dependency logic.

Ultra-wide context memory across sessions

Claude’s 200 k-token window—extendable in some enterprise tiers—lets it hold dozens of sheets or multiple workbooks in active memory at once, so you can hop between tabs, quote passages verbatim, and keep long chains of conversation without re-uploading or re-chunking data.

Inline “Analysis Tool” JavaScript snippets

Within the Analysis Tool pane, Claude can inject and rerun JavaScript helpers to sort rows, deduplicate lists, or compute quick sums/averages; every snippet remains editable, allowing iterative refinement without leaving the chat.

Smart sheet indexing and narrative stitching

On first load, Claude auto-generates a hidden index of sheet names, header rows, and detected topics; this enables queries like “summarize all rows labeled ‘Risk’ across every sheet,” after which it assembles a coherent narrative that cites cell addresses for easy back-tracking.

Bulk comment and note extraction

Claude can scrape all cell comments, threaded notes, and metadata into a single markdown table, then classify them by sentiment or topic—handy for auditing collaboration trails or preparing management summaries.

Lightweight numeric roll-ups

Although it can’t run Excel formulas, Claude can parse visible values across thousands of rows and perform basic arithmetic (totals, counts, averages) entirely in-context, returning quick dashboards without writing back to the file.

•••

When to choose ChatGPT and when to choose Claude

Scenario	Recommended tool	Key reasons
Heavy numerical analysis (statistics, regressions, KPIs, simulations)	ChatGPT	Runs Python code with scientific libraries, processes multiple sheets in one pipeline, generates real-time charts, exports updated files.
Formula auditing and chain-of-calculation checks	ChatGPT	Uses openpyxl to read formulas, identifies broken references, suggests corrections, verifies consistency across sheets.
Data cleansing and structured normalization	ChatGPT	Automates deduplication, data type corrections, and filling in of missing values.
Text search and summarization in large workbooks	Claude	Loads the full content into memory, extracts thematic phrases or paragraphs without breaking the file into parts.
Cross-referencing many Excel files at once	Claude	Holds multiple uploads in memory, connects textual references, and returns combined summaries.
Quick dashboards or charts	ChatGPT (for more numeric control) / Claude (for basic JS-based visuals)	ChatGPT generates matplotlib or plotly charts that are downloadable; Claude creates basic visuals in the Artifacts pane, but doesn’t compute underlying formulas.

Additional limitations of Claude in numerical tasks

• No formula execution: if you change an input, Claude cannot recalculate; it can only describe how the result might change qualitatively.

• Potential inconsistencies with large numeric tables: internal CSV conversion may truncate formats, lose significant zeros, or distort custom date formats.

• Timeout on heavy processing: its Analysis Tool’s JavaScript runs within limited constraints; loops over very wide tables may stop after ~30 seconds.

• Basic charting only: visuals produced in the Artifacts panel lack professional-level customization.

• No built-in numeric validation: it won’t warn you about divide-by-zero errors, #N/A issues, or inconsistencies between sheets; it simply displays the final values without alerting you to anomalies.

Simple calculations across many sheets or long lists

• Claude: For basic operations like totals, counts, or averages that involve simple arithmetic spread across dozens of sheets or very long lists, Claude can be used to “scan” values and compute sums or averages within the chat. Since it loads all the data into its memory, the operation is fast as long as file size stays within limits. However, there’s a lack of formula awareness, and Claude can’t apply dynamic filters or conditions unless you manually guide it step-by-step.

• ChatGPT: In the same scenario, ChatGPT reads the entire workbook using Python, loops through the sheets, aggregates values, and returns a single result, often in just one prompt. It can also produce a new Excel file with totals already filled in. This method is more reliable on large datasets, allows for filters (e.g., “sum only rows where status = ‘APPROVED’”), and makes repetition easy—but you must ensure the file stays under the 50 MB limit.

_______

FOLLOW US FOR MORE.

DATA STUDIOS

datastudios.org