top of page
Search

How Cloud Computing Implementation Costs Are Accounted for under IFRS and US GAAP

ree

Cloud computing arrangements, including software-as-a-service (SaaS), platform-as-a-service (PaaS), and infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS), are now standard in both large corporations and SMEs. Their accounting, however, poses complex classification issues. Under IFRS (primarily IAS 38 and IFRIC guidance) and US GAAP (ASC 350-40), the main challenge is determining whether the arrangement contains a software license (intangible asset) or represents a service contract.

This distinction affects whether implementation costs are capitalized or expensed, how amortization occurs, and how ongoing subscription fees are treated. Both frameworks aim to match the cost recognition pattern with the period of benefit derived from the cloud solution.

·····

.....

How to determine whether a cloud arrangement includes a software license

IFRS perspective:A customer recognizes an intangible asset if it has the right to control the underlying software—meaning it can run the software on its own infrastructure or another cloud provider’s environment without ongoing vendor involvement.

If the customer cannot take possession of the software independently, the arrangement is a service contract, and payments are expensed as incurred.

US GAAP perspective (ASC 350-40):The same test applies. If the arrangement includes a license, apply ASC 350-40 (Internal-Use Software) and capitalize implementation costs.If it is a service-only arrangement, treat it under ASC 720-35 (Other Expenses), with limited capitalization for implementation activities as clarified by ASU 2018-15.

Example:A company subscribes to a cloud-based ERP system that it cannot host independently. → Service contract.Another company buys perpetual software rights and uses the vendor’s hosting temporarily. → License.

·····

.....

How implementation costs are treated under IFRS

Under IAS 38 (Intangible Assets), implementation costs can be capitalized only if they meet recognition criteria:

  • The entity controls the resource.

  • Future economic benefits are probable.

  • Costs are measurable reliably.

If these conditions are not met, costs are expensed.

Capitalized examples:

  • Configuration or customization that creates identifiable functionality.

  • Integration with existing systems that enhance long-term use.

Expensed examples:

  • Training staff to use the system.

  • Data migration or vendor setup fees.

Example – IFRS journal entries:Implementation cost (qualifying): 250,000Monthly service fee: 10,000

  • Debit: Intangible Asset – Cloud Software 250,000

  • Credit: Cash 250,000

  • Debit: Cloud Service Expense 10,000

  • Credit: Cash 10,000

Capitalized amounts are amortized over the useful life, typically the non-cancellable contract term plus renewal options likely to be exercised.

·····

.....

How implementation costs are treated under US GAAP

ASC 350-40 distinguishes between:

  1. Preliminary project stage — expense all costs (research, feasibility).

  2. Application development stage — capitalize costs directly related to software configuration or coding.

  3. Post-implementation stage — expense (training, maintenance).

For cloud service arrangements (ASU 2018-15):Implementation costs may be capitalized even if the contract does not convey a software license, provided they are analogous to internal-use software development.

Amortize capitalized costs on a straight-line basis over the non-cancellable term of the cloud arrangement.

Example – GAAP journal entries:

  • Debit: Deferred Implementation Cost 300,000

  • Credit: Cash 300,000


    Amortization (monthly over 36 months):

  • Debit: Amortization Expense 8,333

  • Credit: Deferred Implementation Cost 8,333

·····

.....

Comparative framework between IFRS and US GAAP

Aspect

IFRS (IAS 38)

US GAAP (ASC 350-40 / ASU 2018-15)

License vs service distinction

Based on control and separability

Based on ability to control software independently

Capitalization criteria

Control, future benefit, reliable measurement

Stage-based: development vs maintenance

Service-only arrangements

Expense as incurred

Expense except certain implementation costs

Amortization period

Useful life or contract term

Contract term (including renewals likely to be exercised)

Presentation

Intangible asset or prepaid expense

Prepaid asset (other current/non-current)

Subsequent fees

Expense as incurred

Expense as incurred

Disclosure requirement

Nature, carrying amount, amortization policy

Nature, amortization period, expense classification

·····

.....

Disclosure requirements for cloud computing arrangements

Entities must provide clarity on the accounting policy and carrying amounts of deferred implementation costs.

IFRS disclosures (IAS 38):

  • Description of intangible assets recognized.

  • Amortization method and useful life.

  • Additions and disposals during the period.

  • Reconciliation of opening and closing carrying amounts.

US GAAP disclosures (ASU 2018-15):

  • Nature of implementation costs capitalized.

  • Amortization expense recognized.

  • Classification within financial statements (typically “Other Assets”).

Example disclosure table:

Item

Amount (USD)

Classification

Implementation Costs

300,000

Deferred Asset

Amortization Expense (Year 1)

100,000

Operating Expense

Remaining Deferred Balance

200,000

Non-current Asset

·····

.....

Journal entries summary

1) Capitalize qualifying implementation cost:

  • Debit: Intangible Asset / Deferred Implementation Cost xx

  • Credit: Cash xx

2) Amortization over contract term:

  • Debit: Amortization Expense xx

  • Credit: Intangible Asset xx

3) Service fees:

  • Debit: Cloud Service Expense xx

  • Credit: Cash xx

4) Non-qualifying costs (training, migration):

  • Debit: Expense xx

  • Credit: Cash xx

·····

.....

Impact on financial performance and ratios

Capitalizing implementation costs smooths profit recognition over time and reduces initial expenses. The accounting treatment impacts:

  • EBITDA: higher if implementation costs are capitalized.

  • ROA: potentially higher due to deferred cost amortization.

  • Cash flow classification: implementation payments → investing activities (IFRS), operating or investing (GAAP depending on classification).

Expensing all costs upfront, on the other hand, compresses profitability in early years but avoids long-term asset amortization.

·····

.....

Operational considerations

Companies should:

  • Distinguish between configuration, customization, and maintenance costs early in project planning.

  • Align contract term assumptions between accounting and procurement.

  • Maintain documentation linking costs to functionality achieved.

  • Periodically reassess the useful life and impairment indicators of deferred implementation assets.

  • Ensure consistent disclosure of amortization and service expenses.

Accurate application of IFRS and US GAAP for cloud implementation costs ensures that digital transformation spending is aligned with the economic benefits realized over time, offering investors a transparent view of capital allocation efficiency.

·····

.....

FOLLOW US FOR MORE

DATA STUDIOS

bottom of page