top of page

IFRIC 12 vs ASC 853 service concessions: financial or intangible asset

1 hour ago
12 min read
Cover reading IFRIC 12 vs ASC 853 service concessions: financial or intangible asset over a night city skyline. Data Studios original cover

A private operator that builds a toll road, a hospital or a water plant for a government, and then runs it for twenty or thirty years, does not record the infrastructure as its own property, plant and equipment under either IFRS or US GAAP. IFRIC 12 Service Concession Arrangements and ASC 853 Service Concession Arrangements agree on that point. They part ways on what the operator records instead. IFRIC 12 requires the operator to recognize a financial asset when the grantor guarantees the cash, an intangible asset when the operator only receives a right to charge users, or both when the arrangement mixes the two. ASC 853 prescribes no such model and sends the operator to other Topics, while stating that the grantor is the customer of the operation services in all cases.


The choice between the two IFRIC 12 models changes the income statement for decades. Under the financial asset model the operator earns construction revenue, then finance income on a receivable that runs down as the grantor pays. Under the intangible asset model the operator earns construction revenue, then toll revenue from users, against which it amortizes the concession right. Borrowing costs incurred during construction are expensed under the first model and capitalized under the second. In the worked example below, the same road built for USD 90,000 thousand produces year-one profit of USD 6,300 thousand under the financial asset model and USD 9,000 thousand under the intangible asset model, with the whole difference coming from borrowing costs.


The question arises at contract signature, when the operator must read the payment mechanism, and again whenever the arrangement is renegotiated. It also arises for US registrants with IFRS-reporting parents, or for groups that report under both frameworks, because the same contract can produce different asset types and different revenue attribution in the two sets of books.


··········


WHEN AN ARRANGEMENT FALLS WITHIN IFRIC 12.


IFRIC 12 paragraph 5 applies to public-to-private arrangements when two conditions are met. The grantor controls or regulates what services the operator must provide with the infrastructure, to whom it must provide them, and at what price. The grantor also controls, through ownership, beneficial entitlement or otherwise, any significant residual interest in the infrastructure at the end of the term. Paragraph 6 adds that infrastructure used for its entire useful life, a so-called whole-of-life asset, is within scope if the first condition is met.


The application guidance makes both conditions practical. Price control does not need to be complete, and a capping mechanism set by a regulator is enough. Control of the residual interest must restrict the operator's practical ability to sell or pledge the infrastructure and give the grantor a continuing right of use through the term. When the grantor holds both, the operator is managing the infrastructure on the grantor's behalf, and IFRIC 12 paragraph 11 concludes that the arrangement does not convey the right to control the use of the infrastructure to the operator. The infrastructure therefore stays off the operator's balance sheet as property, plant and equipment.


Paragraph 12 then describes the operator as a service provider. It constructs or upgrades the infrastructure and operates and maintains it for a specified period, and it accounts for both activities as revenue from contracts with customers under IFRS 15. Paragraphs 14 and 20 send construction or upgrade services and operation services to IFRS 15 separately, which means each is a performance obligation with its own share of the transaction price. For a contractor, the construction phase is normally recognized over time, as covered in our analysis of over-time versus point-in-time revenue recognition under IFRS 15 and ASC 606.


··········


IFRIC 12 FINANCIAL ASSET MODEL VS INTANGIBLE ASSET MODEL.


Paragraph 15 states that the consideration for construction or upgrade services may be rights to a financial asset or to an intangible asset, and paragraphs 16 to 18 set the dividing line by reference to who bears demand risk.


The operator recognizes a financial asset to the extent it has an unconditional contractual right to receive cash or another financial asset from the grantor (paragraph 16). The grantor has little or no discretion to avoid payment, usually because the agreement is enforceable by law. Paragraph 16 also covers guarantees: if the grantor contractually guarantees specified or determinable amounts, or the shortfall between amounts received from users and those amounts, the operator has a financial asset for the guaranteed part, even when payment depends on the operator meeting quality or efficiency requirements. Availability payments for a hospital or a prison typically have this character.


The operator recognizes an intangible asset to the extent it receives a right, described as a license, to charge users of the public service (paragraph 17). A right to charge users is not an unconditional right to receive cash, because the amounts depend on how much the public uses the service. A toll road with no traffic guarantee is the standard case.


When the grantor pays partly through a guarantee and partly through a right to charge users, paragraph 18 requires each component to be accounted for separately, with both measured initially under IFRS 15. Paragraph 19 adds that, during the construction or upgrade period, both types of consideration are classified as a contract asset.


After construction the two assets follow different standards. The financial asset falls under IAS 32, IFRS 7 and IFRS 9 (paragraphs 23 to 25) and is measured at amortized cost, at fair value through other comprehensive income, or at fair value through profit or loss, depending on its IFRS 9 classification; where it is at amortized cost or fair value through other comprehensive income, interest is recognized with the effective interest method. The classification tests are the general ones described in our piece on how financial instruments are classified and measured under IFRS 9 and ASC 320/825. The intangible asset falls under IAS 38 (paragraph 26), with amortization over the concession period and impairment testing as for any other finite-lived intangible, covered in how intangible assets are measured on the balance sheet.


Three further rules complete the IFRIC 12 picture. Paragraph 22 requires borrowing costs attributable to the arrangement to be expensed as incurred unless the operator has a contractual right to receive an intangible asset, in which case they are capitalized during construction under IAS 23. Paragraph 21 requires contractual obligations to maintain the infrastructure to a specified level of serviceability, or to restore it before handover, to be recognized and measured under IAS 37 at the best estimate of the expenditure required at the reporting date, except for any upgrade element, which is a construction service. Paragraph 27 states that items the grantor gives the operator, which the operator can keep or deal with as it wishes, are part of the transaction price and are not government grants under IAS 20.


··········


SERVICE CONCESSIONS UNDER ASC 853.


US GAAP addressed the topic later and more narrowly. ASU 2014-05 created Topic 853 with two core requirements. An operating entity does not account for a service concession arrangement within scope as a lease, and the infrastructure is not recognized as property, plant and equipment of the operating entity (853-10-25-2). Revenue and costs for construction, upgrade and operation services were sent to the revenue Topic then in force (853-10-25-1), now Topic 606.


The scope conditions resemble IFRIC 12 with differences in wording. The grantor must be a public-sector entity, which includes a governmental body or an entity to which responsibility for the public service has been delegated (853-10-15-3). The grantor must control or have the ability to modify or approve the services the operator provides, to whom, and at what price, with the price allowed to sit within a specified range. The grantor must also control, through ownership, beneficial entitlement or otherwise, any residual interest in the infrastructure at the end of the term. Arrangements within the scope of Topic 980 on regulated operations follow Topic 980 instead.


The basis for conclusions of ASU 2014-05 states that the Emerging Issues Task Force decided not to include specific guidance on what asset, if any, the operating entity should recognize for the infrastructure. ASC 853 therefore has no financial asset model and no intangible asset model. The operator determines the asset from the contract terms and the applicable Topics: a contract asset or receivable under Topic 606 for consideration from the grantor, and the general guidance on financial assets and intangible assets for anything else.


ASU 2017-10 added the rule that most distinguishes US GAAP from IFRIC 12. It amended 853-10-25-1 so that the operating entity considers the grantor to be the customer of its operation services in all cases. The basis for conclusions explains that the operator acts as the grantor's service provider and that the only parties to the executed arrangement are the grantor and the operator. It also records that this conclusion is not consistent with the demand-risk approach of IFRIC 12, and that it is specific to Topic 853 and should not be applied by analogy to other arrangements. The amendments took effect with Topic 606 adoption for entities that had not yet adopted it, and for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2017 (public business entities and certain others) or December 15, 2018 (all other entities) for those that had.


The practical consequence for a US operator collecting tolls is that revenue analysis is anchored on the contract with the grantor, even though the cash comes from drivers. The operator still identifies its performance obligations, estimates variable consideration and applies the constraint under Topic 606, but it does so with the grantor as the customer.


··········


IFRIC 12 VS ASC 853 COMPARISON TABLE.


........


Issue

IFRIC 12

ASC 853

Grantor

Public sector, or private entity with delegated responsibility

Public-sector entity, including delegated entities

Infrastructure as operator PP&E

No (paragraph 11)

No (853-10-25-2)

Lease accounting by operator

No, unless a separable lease exists (IFRS 16)

No (Topic 840, now Topic 842)

Construction revenue

IFRS 15

Topic 606

Asset model

Financial asset, intangible asset, or both

Not prescribed; other Topics apply

Customer of operation services

Depends on terms and demand risk

Grantor in all cases (ASU 2017-10)

Borrowing costs in construction

Capitalized only for an intangible right (IAS 23)

No Topic 853 rule; ASC 835-20 judgment

Maintenance and restoration

IAS 37 provision

Other Topics apply

Effective date

Periods beginning on or after 1 January 2008

ASU 2014-05 from periods after December 15, 2014


........


The table shows where convergence ends. Both frameworks keep the infrastructure off the operator's fixed-asset register and both treat construction as a revenue contract. IFRIC 12 then gives a detailed answer on the asset and its subsequent measurement, while ASC 853 leaves those questions to general guidance and gives a single, firm answer on the identity of the customer.


··········


WORKED EXAMPLE: A TOLL ROAD UNDER BOTH IFRIC 12 MODELS.


The figures are illustrative and in USD thousands. An operator signs a ten-year concession to build and run a road. Construction takes one year and costs 90,000. The operator prices construction at cost plus 10%, so the stand-alone selling price of the construction service is 99,000. The operator borrows to fund construction and incurs 2,700 of interest during the build. Operation services cost 1,800 a year and have a stand-alone selling price of 2,000 a year. For simplicity construction revenue is recognized within year 1 and the financing effect during the build is ignored; in a multi-year build the operator would also assess the significant financing component under IFRS 15 and ASC 606.


Scenario A is the financial asset model. The grantor pays a fixed availability charge of 16,000 at the end of each of years 2 to 11, regardless of traffic. Of each payment, 2,000 is for operation services and 14,000 repays the construction receivable. The effective interest rate that discounts ten payments of 14,000 to 99,000 is 6.85%, so year-2 interest income is 6,785 and the receivable falls to 91,785 at the end of year 2. Over the ten years, total interest income is 41,000, equal to the 140,000 of construction payments less the 99,000 receivable.


Scenario B is the intangible asset model. The grantor pays nothing; the operator collects tolls from drivers and bears traffic risk. Year-2 toll revenue is 18,000. The concession intangible equals the 99,000 construction revenue plus 2,700 of capitalized borrowing costs, or 101,700, amortized straight-line over ten years at 10,170 a year.


........


Entry

Account

Debit

Credit

A1 Year 1

Contract asset

99,000


A1 Year 1

Construction revenue


99,000

A2 Year 1

Construction costs

90,000


A2 Year 1

Cash / payables


90,000

A3 Year 1

Interest expense

2,700


A3 Year 1

Cash


2,700

A4 Completion

Financial asset (concession receivable)

99,000


A4 Completion

Contract asset


99,000

A5 Year 2

Financial asset (concession receivable)

6,785


A5 Year 2

Finance income


6,785

A6 Year 2

Cash

16,000


A6 Year 2

Financial asset (concession receivable)


14,000

A6 Year 2

Operation services revenue


2,000

A7 Year 2

Operating costs

1,800


A7 Year 2

Cash


1,800


........


........


Entry

Account

Debit

Credit

B1 Year 1

Contract asset

99,000


B1 Year 1

Construction revenue


99,000

B2 Year 1

Construction costs

90,000


B2 Year 1

Cash / payables


90,000

B3 Year 1

Intangible asset (concession right)

2,700


B3 Year 1

Cash


2,700

B4 Completion

Intangible asset (concession right)

99,000


B4 Completion

Contract asset


99,000

B5 Year 2

Cash

18,000


B5 Year 2

Toll revenue


18,000

B6 Year 2

Amortization expense

10,170


B6 Year 2

Accumulated amortization


10,170

B7 Year 2

Operating costs

1,800


B7 Year 2

Cash


1,800


........


Every entry balances. The profit effect of the two models in the first two years is summarized below.


........


Profit line

A: financial asset

B: intangible asset

Year 1 construction margin

9,000

9,000

Year 1 interest expense

(2,700)

0

Year 1 profit before tax

6,300

9,000

Year 2 revenue

2,000

18,000

Year 2 finance income

6,785

0

Year 2 amortization and costs

(1,800)

(11,970)

Year 2 profit before tax

6,985

6,030

Asset at end of year 2

91,785

91,530


........


The intangible asset at the end of year 2 is 101,700 less one year of amortization, or 91,530. Under the financial asset model, profit after construction tracks a declining interest curve plus a thin operating margin; under the intangible model it tracks traffic, less a fixed amortization charge. A US operator reporting under ASC 853 would recognize the same construction revenue under Topic 606, but it would determine the asset from the contract and general guidance, and in scenario B it would treat the grantor as the customer of the operation services even though drivers pay the tolls.


··········


PRESENTATION AND DISCLOSURE OF SERVICE CONCESSIONS.


IFRIC 12 contains no disclosure list of its own; paragraph 10 points to SIC-29 Service Concession Arrangements: Disclosures. In practice operators describe the arrangement, its significant terms, the rights and obligations for use of the infrastructure, renewal and termination options, and changes during the period, alongside the disclosures that IFRS 15, IFRS 9 and IAS 38 require for the revenue, the financial asset and the intangible asset. Finance income on the concession receivable and amortization of the concession right are presented in the lines that the operator's general presentation policies dictate.


ASC 853 likewise adds no recurring disclosure list beyond the transition disclosures of its two updates. The operator relies on the disclosure requirements of Topic 606 for revenue, including disaggregation and contract balances, and of the Topics that govern whatever assets and obligations it recognizes.


··········


COMMON ERRORS IN SERVICE CONCESSION ACCOUNTING.


The most frequent error is recognizing the infrastructure as property, plant and equipment because the operator built it, paid for it and runs it. Both frameworks reject that result once the grantor controls the services, the price and the residual interest, and the error inflates fixed assets and depreciation while omitting construction revenue.


A second error is classifying a guaranteed payment stream as an intangible asset, or a pure toll right as a receivable. Under IFRIC 12 the test is whether the grantor has little or no discretion to avoid payment, and a minimum revenue guarantee creates a financial asset for the guaranteed part even when the rest of the consideration is a right to charge users. Splitting mixed arrangements requires the guaranteed amount to be measured first, with the intangible asset covering the remainder.


A third error concerns borrowing costs. Operators applying the financial asset model sometimes capitalize interest by analogy with ordinary construction projects, although IFRIC 12 paragraph 22 requires it to be expensed. Under US GAAP, Topic 853 contains no interest capitalization rule, so whether ASC 835-20 applies depends on whether the operator holds an asset that qualifies, a judgment that should be documented.


A fourth error is treating resurfacing or major maintenance as an upgrade, or the reverse. A contractual obligation to restore the road to a specified condition before handover is an IAS 37 provision built up as the obligation arises; work that extends capacity or service level is a further construction service with its own revenue and its own consideration.


A final error affects groups reporting under both frameworks: applying the IFRIC 12 demand-risk reasoning to identify the customer under US GAAP. ASU 2017-10 removed that option, and the FASB stated that its conclusion should not be extended by analogy outside Topic 853.


··········


PRACTICAL CHECKLIST FOR AN OPERATOR.


........


Step

Question

Where to look

1

Does the grantor control services, users and price?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 5; ASC 853-10-15

2

Does the grantor control the residual interest?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 5(b); ASC 853-10-15

3

Is any part of the infrastructure a separable lease?

IFRIC 12 AG8; IFRS 16 or Topic 842

4

Which amounts does the grantor guarantee?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 16

5

Which amounts depend on user demand?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 17

6

Are borrowing costs capitalized or expensed?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 22; ASC 835-20

7

Which maintenance obligations need a provision?

IFRIC 12 paragraph 21; IAS 37

8

Who is the customer of operation services?

ASU 2017-10 for US GAAP


........


··········


IFRIC 12 AND ASC 853 SERVICE CONCESSIONS: JUDGMENT AREAS.


The two frameworks agree on the starting point: in a public-sector concession that meets the control and residual-interest tests, the operator does not own the infrastructure and accounts for construction and operation as revenue contracts. IFRIC 12 then turns the payment mechanism into an accounting model, with a receivable for guaranteed cash, a concession intangible for a right to charge users, and a split between the two when the contract mixes them. That classification determines whether borrowing costs are capitalized and whether later profit follows an interest curve or traffic volumes.


US GAAP stops earlier. ASC 853 removes lease and property, plant and equipment accounting, sends revenue to Topic 606 and fixes the grantor as the customer of the operation services, but leaves the asset itself to general guidance. The open questions for preparers are the classification of minimum revenue guarantees, the measurement of the components in mixed arrangements, the treatment of interest during construction under ASC 835-20, the line between maintenance and upgrades, and, for dual reporters, the reconciliation of customer identification between the two frameworks.


··········


FOLLOW US FOR MORE.


·····


DATA STUDIOS


·····


datastudios.org


bottom of page